Quote Originally Posted by Ankhira View Post
Are you deliberately missing the point, or what? Saying a tiny group of disgusting people represents FFXIV as a whole is illogical and ignorant. By that logic, if a criminal ring uses iPhones, then Apple and every iPhone user is implicated too, right? A microscopic fraction of awful people using an MMO/Discord doesn't make it indicative of a game with millions of normal players. It’s an issue with those specific individuals.
You’re arguing with a claim I didn’t make. I literally said one alleged ring does not prove FF14 as a whole has some uniquely bad problem.

The question is whether the particular social environment it existed in mattered at all. That’s completely different from saying every FF14 player is implicated.

And the iPhone analogy is nonsensical. You can't just use an analogy and pretend you're saying something. An iPhone is a tool. An MMORPG community is a social ecosystem with specific norms and practices. If abuse repeatedly develops inside a particular community, it’s perfectly reasonable to ask whether features of that environment made it easier to organize, conceal, or ignore. Those things clearly affect how misconduct spreads or gets detected. Saying that only those individuals are guilty and saying the surrounding community structure may still be relevant are not contradictory statements. Pretending they are is just a way to avoid examining the second question.

You know what, maybe I will take it there. Are we seriously going to pretend FF14 hasn’t earned a reputation for sexual deviancy in its social scene? I’m not talking about every player obviously. But, I’m talking about the unusually visible ERP culture, e-dating, bathhouses galore, sexual mods, stalking scandals, etc etc. You simply do not see that same combination as prominently woven into the social identity of the top MMORGs today. WoW has its ERP hotspots, sure. OSRS barely has anything comparable as a serious social subculture. FF14 is different in an alarming degree, and pretending otherwise is just being disingenuous.