We Dub to Make it Our Own..

[Saieno]

It's really hard to tell what they were looking for judging by the winner, no offense to him but it sounds very similar to the original trailer in my opinion; just deeper. I heard some great voice overs I think were better than some of the winners; but hey I'm not a Square-Enix team member lol.

[Dargoth_Draconia]

Honestly out of all the winners or runner ups "Aqualin Riversong - Excalibur" was the best by far and was the only one out of any of them that had any feeling/emotion in his voice over. The rest of them lacked something even when compared to the original voice over that SE put out.

It's really hard to tell what they were looking for judging by the winner, no offense to him but it sounds very similar to the original trailer in my opinion; just deeper. I heard some great voice overs I think were better than some of the winners; but hey I'm not a Square-Enix team member lol.

Rofl, I was thinking the exact same thing and I thought the original was better actually.

[Neptune]

The winning entries are all pretty horrible. They all sound like people throwing their voice and trying to sound like something that is allegedly what, an Eorzean pirate? That's what got us into this bind of a horrible sounding trailer in the first place. What's up with no female winners? A couple of the female entries were genuinely interesting to my American ears and sounded much more authentic.

[Rannie]

The winning entries are all pretty horrible. They all sound like people throwing their voice and trying to to sound like something that is allegedly what, an Eorzean pirate? That's what got us into this bind of a horrible sounding trailer in the first place. What's up with no female winners? A couple of the female entries were genuinely interesting to my American ears and sounded much more authentic.

Yeah and when I say something about it. I get called a troll when i say it seems to be sexist.

[Goufunaki]

Grats to the winner!




Also...

The winning entries are all pretty horrible. They all sound like people throwing their voice and trying to to sound like something that is allegedly what, an Eorzean pirate? That's what got us into this bind of a horrible sounding trailer in the first place. What's up with no female winners? A couple of the female entries were genuinely interesting to my American ears and sounded much more authentic.

Honestly out of all the winners or runner ups "Aqualin Riversong - Excalibur" was the best by far and was the only one out of any of them that had any feeling/emotion in his voice over. The rest of them lacked something even when compared to the original voice over that SE put out.

"What did you expect? They'd come out quoting 'Macbeth'?"

[Rannie]

Double double toil and trouble fire burn and cauldron bubble.

[Neptune]

lol. Well nonetheless grats to you Rammsteinn.

Yeah and when I say something about it. I get called a troll when i say it seems to be sexist.

I think that's going a little too far. There's no reason to think any of the judges were suddenly sexist. I think it's much more likely that in their difficulty picking a criteria to judge by they wound up with one that excluded females. Remember when Yoshi-P decided to get rid of all the player communities for the server merge? lol. Sometimes your final choice isn't your best. lol

[Rannie]

lol. Well nonetheless grats to you Rammsteinn.



I think that's going a little too far. There's no reason to think any of the judges were suddenly sexist. I think it's much more likely that in their difficulty picking a criteria to judge by they wound up with one that excluded females. Remember when Yoshi-P decided to get rid of all the player communities for the server merge? lol. Sometimes your final choice isn't your best. lol

Oh I wasn't trying to say they were in the least that they were sexist at all. I was pointing out that some people can and will consider it sexist. A point that I should have made more clearer when I typed up my post though I thought it would be slightly obvious when I didn't say that's so sexist but when I said it seems to be a bit sexist.

[AsterBarnivere]

The winner sounds like SE hired Keith David xD (I like Keith David btw)

[Goufunaki]

Alright, now that I actually listened to the other winners, I really liked Aqualin's entry best. Good job!

Mine just sounds a bit forced. o_O