While I hypothetically approve of adding 'specializations' to the classes, I was there when WAR was the optimal MT just because it could hold aggro while still having Deliverance on. The reason the rework to tanks and tank stances happened in the first place was because of this nonsense. I would not be surprised if we end up with "aggro juggling" in high end content just to squeeze out some extra damage out of the Main Tank roles, because god only knows the only thing that matters in Savage content is more damage (The community, of which, the design of the entire job system seems to revolve around). And while all of this is happening, DRK, WAR, and GNB will fall by the wayside because they 'aren't optimal.' Just look at how bad machinist got shafted for dealing slightly less damage than everyone else.

We've had some solutions thrown around, but they are constantly dismissed for the sake of expediency. During ARR, cross-class skills were scrapped because they were annoying to get, even though the utility and personal expression they offered the player were not insignificant. Bozja offered players a dozen different ways to play the same class with their skills and essences. Even Phantom Jobs add unique sub-identities and abilities to run content with. But time after time, the excuse is 'People would just use the most optimal loadout.' But that doesn't really justify not getting a choice in the matter. Sure, you can 'just play a different job,' but sometimes you like the way something looks or feels, damnit.

That's the real issue. Not that 'off tank' is a new sub-role, but that you don't really get a choice in the matter. I think CBU3 realize one of the reasons people play this game is to express themselves through their character. The updates to the character creation system (my main gripe with which is honestly just that the people I least want to be using it will be the people who use it) are a step in the right direction. But this game is long, long overdue for permanent ACTION customization. Not just more skins for actions. Real changes to the way you play.