All it needs is having the buff that gives the counter proc be packed in both Holy Sheltron and Intervention, which I genuinely expect them to do.

From what I also saw with the counter attack, it actually had two charges of like... 40s recharge, so if you can't find a moment to use Holy Sheltron to proc that in 40s (or 80s if you use the second one soon after the first one), I'd be genuinely surprised. So it isn't even comparable to Shield Swipe's 15s cooldown (which didnt even have charges back then).

Also, Heavensward Dark Knight was not really an off-tank considering you wanted to proc parries when you could - the main reason you brought DRK WAR is because of how prevalent magic damage was, which Paladin could not block on top of having a 180s cooldown on Sentinel and absolutely nothing against magical raidwides.