Quote Originally Posted by Pixieh View Post
This is not me dooming, this is me speaking from experiencing it in different games over and over again and being realistic about the vast majority of the playerbase in ANY mmorpg.
While that's true, you need to keep in mind that FFXIV uniquely doesn't have an actual class role setup of value. Not really. It's the closest to what GW2 did properly, remove tanks/healers/damage as a concept. In FFXIV, only your damage ever matters. So whether Paladin is god or Paladin is trash isn't decided by how good they are as a main tank, offtank or second healer, it's solely decided by whether they deal 2% more or less damage than Bastion. All this split does is ensure that of the two groups of tanks, Paladin/Bastion and Gunbreaker/Darkknight/Warrior, one each will be present in Full Party content, probably. We don't even know whether they'll get them closely-balanced enough for that. Whether a Gunbreaker takes 15% more damage as a main tank has absolutely 0 bearing on how we build parties, if they deal 3% extra damage they'll be the MT instead of a Pally or DW-Pally.

In a way, this solves a potential issue. Because on paper I agree, this has happened before. But in FFXIV it cannot happen as roles such as tank, or sub-roles such as ranged vs melee DPS, only hold any value when they modify the damage output. Never for their actual role or combat range or anything like that.

(Regardless of that I enjoy upsides and downsides to classes so big that they're the kings of one type of content while being strictly inferior in others, but I might be showing that even Aion is "too new" for my taste there, I fell in love with CRPGs in older games where the pen&paper heritage was still stronger and hence identity and uniqueness mattered far far far far more than balance capability nevermind actual balance, and being able to do XYZ despite using the inferior setup for it was seen as something cool to do!)