Quote Originally Posted by Carighan View Post
So, easy balance:
* MTs deal 95% damage.
* To get that missing 5%, they need to be actively attacked.
* OTs deal 100% damage.
* However, they lose 5% of that damage when they engage their active self-protection continuously.
If players saw this on release, they'd just lock out main tanks entirely and run two off-tanks on swaps/invulns. If the off tanks take more damage as a result, then the expectation will be that the healers will sort it out.

I'm reminded of Stormblood's tank accessory fiasco. The dev team wanted tanks to stop using STR accessories, so they role locked the new accessories and made them VIT only (such that tank accessories didn't provide meaningful damage progression). Tanks went back to the previous expansion's STR accessories (i270) and used them instead, while making their healers cross-compensate for the loss of eHP. They backtracked pretty much immediately.

That being said, I would be surprised if counters make up a large portion of main tank damage, because the devs are averse to penalizing players for rotational mistakes (such as missing counters or not planning for them). But even a small dps imbalance between the subroles can be enough for players to start enforcing double main tank or double off tank setups, if there's not enough of a difference between the subroles outside of that.

I think that if you want this role split to work, it needs to be through mitigation/utility. If a particular job provides a simpler way of solving a mechanic, then you'll still want to take that job regardless of small dps variations between jobs. Give players a reason to want to run one of each subrole, rather than trying to force them to play this way.