Quote Originally Posted by Mikey_R View Post
Let's not base things on initial reactions, stop, think and make logical conclusions.
While obviously speculative by nature, many of these concerns are rooted in "logical conclusions" because SE is rather notorious for pigeonhole designs then refusing to pull back on them when it doesn't work. The whole healer split is an example of that already wherein one pair of healers (Barrier) is demonstrably better than the other. Another example would be the Prange. They literally had to introduce a party buff then subsequently increase it because the Prange damage is so low nobody would ever bring them otherwise. Caster balance has been in the gutter for two expansions now because SE has refused to move off balancing around Raise.

So it's reasonable that people are a bit wary of how splitting tanks into two defined roles will be.