Page 7 of 30 FirstFirst ... 5 6 7 8 9 17 ... LastLast
Results 61 to 70 of 409

Hybrid View

  1. #1
    Player
    Terhix's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2021
    Posts
    198
    Character
    Thane Ryder
    World
    Odin
    Main Class
    Dark Knight Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Terjo View Post
    Losing access to strong counter mechanics or having suboptimal personal mitigation when you want to main tank sucks, especially if you're someone who enjoys flexing between the two roles.
    Every ultimate and multiple savage fights have both tanks take heavy damage, there is no way in hell 3 of the 5 tanks will be "suboptimal" for that or the meta will be to not take offtanks at all. At worst the OT jobs will have some group mits or boss damage debuffs that don't stack, and MTs will have the counter mechanic, so if you stack two of each subrole you will just have to coordinate better, just as two barrier healers have to coordinate right now, neither regen nor shield healer is a "suboptimal" healer.
    (3)

  2. #2
    Player
    Carighan's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2018
    Posts
    2,693
    Character
    Carighan Maconar
    World
    Zodiark
    Main Class
    Paladin Lv 100
    Again the only issue here is the naming. Maybe, as the playerbase can be pretty dramatic at times.. See Bards and White Mages already inventing new ways for the sky to fall because their jobs got shown with semi-interesting gameplay instead of the current boredom they have but All Change Is Bad(tm) as is tradition in FFXIV.

    If they choose names such as "Paragon" vs "Sentinel" or "Defender" vs "Guardian", then all is fine. Yes, "off tank" implies being less good at tanking a little bit. There's a slight indication there, yes. Hence a different naming scheme would be better.

    If we truly want to mirror regen healer vs barrier healer (positive specifier + role name without qualifier) then I would suggest "mitigation tank" vs "protection tank" but really more fantasy names like above work better IMO.

    Quote Originally Posted by Terjo View Post
    The whole MT/OT split (at least in Evolved mode) feels like it came way too late in the game's life, and honestly, its main effect seems to be hurting the tank playerbase more than helping.
    Few notes:
    • This split existed, player-induced, for years already. Players have always figured out which tank is more optimal as tank vs as blue DPS. If anything, the current interchangeability implies the new difference will be absolutely minor as well.
    • Healers being split already implied at *some* point, tanks will do the same, as more and more get added.
    • FFXIV isn't the only MMORPG, this is not new or noteworthy in the grand scheme of things.
    • What is weird is how late this comes, and this is a crucial flaw of FFXIV but in a different way than many seem to assume. FFXIV changed too little in the past. Other MMOs massively iterate their setups every expansion, often ripping out entire core concepts and replacing them, or leaving some behind.

    If FFXIV basically re-did class implementations every expansion like an MMORPG ought to, such a split would have happened back in heavensward or so, and since then have been modified 3-4 times. Tanks would have been very specialized at some point (compare early-TBC era WoW?), very unified at others, and over time they would have found a middle ground that works.

    We're seeing the beginnings of that process, just 10+ years late. But better late than never, in particular because the existing system proved to be untennable (1+ expansion ago, so now in Dawntrail it's laughably fragile as a concept, they really were under a lot of pressure to rip out current classes whole and replace them which they're finally doing).
    (3)
    Last edited by Carighan; 04-27-2026 at 06:46 PM.

  3. #3
    Player
    soymalklatte's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2026
    Location
    Gridania
    Posts
    2
    Character
    Caur Ejinn
    World
    Marilith
    Main Class
    Red Mage Lv 100
    As a Gunbreaker main, I welcome a new challenge to the status quo of the game. We already sort-of have something of a soft MT-OT split, where Gunbreaker and Paladin are undeniably meant to protect other party members, whereas Warrior and Dark Knight are meant to soak damage, dish damage, and heal to a greater extent. (Nascent Flash UwU). Like I said, it's a soft split at best, and has little bearing on whether one can actually MT or OT, but the intention is clearly there, in my opinion. I am moderately surprised to see that they want Paladin to be a Main Tank and for Warrior and Dark Knight to be Off Tanks, but I think that the split is a good thing, and will introduce new challenges and encourage tank mains to learn the intricacies of both sides, which will ultimately be good for people who enjoy tanking as a whole. I mean, we already have a split between pure healers (WHM/AST) and shield healers (SCH/SGE). I'm not terribly surprised that they want to differentiate the tanks to give them a little more job identity.

    This is ultimately about job identity, which Evolved Mode intends to emphasize. And if every tank ultimately does the same thing in Evolved Mode, I really think they would be failing in that goal. The tank jobs need to have an identity just as much as the myriad DPS jobs do.
    (0)

  4. #4
    Player
    Oizen's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2021
    Location
    playing other games like yoshida intended
    Posts
    2,541
    Character
    Alondite Ragnell
    World
    Midgardsormr
    Main Class
    Dark Knight Lv 100
    WAR's entire mitigation kit would need to be compeltely rethought if its going to be an OT.
    DRK basically already fills this role.
    (2)

  5. #5
    Player
    RaionKansen's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2022
    Location
    Ul'dah
    Posts
    487
    Character
    Raion Kansen
    World
    Behemoth
    Main Class
    Samurai Lv 100
    I would like to see what they have planned for OT in higher end content before I say much on the change.
    (1)

  6. #6
    Player
    Derio's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2015
    Posts
    3,529
    Character
    Derio Uzumaki
    World
    Sargatanas
    Main Class
    Dark Knight Lv 100
    I agree with the OP. I think the wording that they used may be off. Right now based on what was shown.

    All tanks can reduce enemy damage-- Reprisal
    PLD and new tank can counter enemy damage
    PLD can provide protection for individual-- intervention
    PLD can provide protection for the party- wings & divine veil

    Right now PLD as what was showed can do everything that was stated in terms of both MT and OT which is why I think their splitting is a wording issue. At EU fanfest we should get more clarification to calm our fears. However people are right to be cautious. Especially what happened with AST to where now playing AST and WHM in high end content can be a death sentence.
    (1)

  7. #7
    Player
    Mukuku's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2026
    Posts
    63
    Character
    Mukuku Muku
    World
    Spriggan
    Main Class
    Dark Knight Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Derio View Post
    Right now PLD as what was showed can do everything that was stated in terms of both MT and OT which is why I think their splitting is a wording issue.
    That is true if the counter mechanic can proc off allies, e.g. through Intervention. If not, not being the actual MT would mean PLD loses the counter mechanic and potentially also potency since my understanding is that countering gives higher damage.

    If e.g. Intervention can trigger counters I agree the issue is only naming, but if it's not there is a strong incentive for the "counter tank" to be the one holding aggro, which is what upsets many players.

    Said that, a similar mechanic already exists with TBN, which needs to be timed right to "pop" on damage and can be put on allies. Popping TBN is damage-neutral whereas non popping it is a damage loss: it would only need to turn the pop into a damage increase to effectively have it as a "counter"...
    (1)

  8. #8
    Player
    RaionKansen's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2022
    Location
    Ul'dah
    Posts
    487
    Character
    Raion Kansen
    World
    Behemoth
    Main Class
    Samurai Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Derio View Post
    I agree with the OP. I think the wording that they used may be off. Right now based on what was shown.

    All tanks can reduce enemy damage-- Reprisal
    PLD and new tank can counter enemy damage
    PLD can provide protection for individual-- intervention
    PLD can provide protection for the party- wings & divine veil

    Right now PLD as what was showed can do everything that was stated in terms of both MT and OT which is why I think their splitting is a wording issue. At EU fanfest we should get more clarification to calm our fears. However people are right to be cautious. Especially what happened with AST to where now playing AST and WHM in high end content can be a death sentence.
    With them also saying that they want healers to focus on healing and that they don't like how bosses kind of just stand around for you to hit them, I think we're going to be seeing much more damage in higher end fights. At least that's what I'm hoping
    (0)

  9. #9
    Player
    Zalifer's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2026
    Posts
    2
    Character
    Zalifer Esepula
    World
    Twintania
    Main Class
    Marauder Lv 98
    If they use a toggle method, my suggestion would be that it cannot be toggled during an encounter/combat. This would mean the tanks need to set up for the fight ahead of time, and doesn't reintroduce "stance dancing" where tanks will play in whatever gives more DPS and swap into MT only for big hits, for example. It allows for the devs to design fights that would require MT/OT roles (which may be the desire here, to introduce more involved tank roles, particularly for the OT), but as any player could likely fill either role on any job, it wouldn't have as large an impact on filling or joining groups. Some players may not wish to MT, some may not wish to OT, but that can happen now too. Even if the difference between roles isn't limited to tuning, but has different skills, those could be changed by the toggle too, of course. Maybe changing "stand your ground" to "stand my ground" when WAR is set to MT, removing it as a party wide, and giving them a larger personal, for example.

    Anyway, this feels like maybe my one negative from the fanfest announcements, but I felt I had to make an account to add my voice to feedback for the team. I feel like there's probably the intention to give some great encounters and fight design in high end content behind this change, I'd just rather the way it's handled be different.
    Almost every single other thing looked good, so I'm still really looking forward to the change to get into raiding, even if I feel a little railroaded into a particular tank role. Maybe iLvl reflection will make it easier for me to swap to another job for the other role though
    (0)

  10. #10
    Player
    Zalifer's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2026
    Posts
    2
    Character
    Zalifer Esepula
    World
    Twintania
    Main Class
    Marauder Lv 98
    I'm not currently playing endgame, but I was hoping to start running raids in the new expansion. Watching the reveal was like seeing someone get everything right, up until the tank split.

    It feels like there's no way that this is a boon for players.

    Lots of defenders of the change are saying that "the split won't matter" which is an awful defence for splitting them into two roles. If it doesn't matter, why separate them into two groups? Why put names that you know, mattering or not, people will select based on, feeling like they need one of each.

    If the change does matter, and newer content forces people to use one MT and one OT, it now forces people who enjoy a job and role they have played for a long time to possibly need to change at one of those things, either swapping role to play their job, or swapping job to play their role. Of course, some people may see their main job and role line up. As for people that are happy to play either role on a job, they now can't play each on the same job, losing flexibilty and player freedom.

    If the requirement for MT and OT is really only something that matters in the highest difficulty of content, then again, why put the names and groups in there? High end duty players already select the jobs that give every little optimisation in a fight, so names or not, they would work out which tanks are best for a given enounter and run those. And that decision will trickle downwards due to "meta". If people see all the top groups running MT/OT, MT/MT, or OT/OT, that will become a common thing to see required even in low level content that doesn't require it.

    Any of the above scenarios would likely result in it being slower and more awkward to fill parties, as you now require the right tanks to fill your group. For tank players, depending on your chosen job, make it harder to get into duties. For example, if meta decides OT/OT is the way to run, PLD is going to find it harder to get into groups. Or if it's MT/OT, OT's may struggle to find groups as there are more people playing OT since it covers 3 jobs, or it could be with so many people trying the new tank (or just wanting to MT) there might be a huge surplus of MT's making it harder for those jobs to find a spot.

    As other people have mentioned, PLD has been shown to tick all the boxes to be both MT and OT by their descriptions given so far. Hence, we might assume (a risk, I know) that all tanks will have a complete toolkit, but the tuning will lean a little one way or the other depending on the MT/OT role they are assigned, with party mit skills being weaker for MT, but having higher defences or tools to mitigate damage on themselves. If that's the case, then perhaps a simple toggle of which role the tank wants to be in would be a better solution would be, as many people have suggested, a way to switch from being MT to OT and back.
    (4)

Page 7 of 30 FirstFirst ... 5 6 7 8 9 17 ... LastLast