
It's not the worst thing in the world to announce early but there's so many questions left unanswered and worries over how early in development it looked for something releasing in less than a year.This is a difficult one as I understand the frustration, we have snippets of things with a lot of 'we are still ironing out exactly how it is going to work, look forward to it', however I suspect they also wanted to show us, look, we are listening, we have massive changes coming to the game and we want everyone to be aware of it. This is not going to be DT2.0, but something different. This is also why they wanted to show some job gameplay far ahead of where we normally see it, we hear you wanting to get away from the battle cycle, so this is what we are working with.
If you were to choose between a fan fest that didn't show anything new and seemed just like the others, or, one where they showed they want to make massive changes, which one would you chose?



Probably the biggest problem is they are introducing this split along with the imbalance of MT and OT numbers. When they did the healer split it was even 2-2.
If anything this is just currently a PR nightmare that was overshadowed by the evolved mode and other many changes.
As some people have suggested, they should just have a toggle stance for Main Tank and Offtank that lets you use different abilities relevant to either. Let every tank job be either or. Them forcing this job restriction is literally forcing statics that have had their favorite jobs to change jobs or break up. My Best friend and Co Tank is a Dark Knight and i'm a main Warrior Tank, we alternate roles, now we cant even play together anymore if we want to support our group? like cmon man.



I mean Square being the kings of not giving a thing about class uniqueness means you are probably more than safe, you'll lose like 0.1% damage or something irrelevant like that I bet. I'm kinda of the opposite opinion anyways: I don't want tanks to fall into two "groups" of having unique setups (but within each group being hyperhomogenized like the four are now), but I want every tank to be unique. Including naturally that there are fights each specific one will be better or worse at. Their own little speciality.As some people have suggested, they should just have a toggle stance for Main Tank and Offtank that lets you use different abilities relevant to either. Let every tank job be either or. Them forcing this job restriction is literally forcing statics that have had their favorite jobs to change jobs or break up. My Best friend and Co Tank is a Dark Knight and i'm a main Warrior Tank, we alternate roles, now we cant even play together anymore if we want to support our group? like cmon man.

Agreeing with this. I hate everything about the idea of HAVING to be a main or off tank based on which tank I'm playing. I want to main tank on jobs I'm good at and off tank on jobs I'm new to, or main tank when I'm feeling good and off tank when I'm tired and out of it. Just give me a toggle.



"Main tanks are for boss aggro and Off Tanks are for ally support."
Thats why PLD has Passage,Veil, Intervention, Clemency oh and the new tank also apparently heals allies.
Meanwhile GNB,WAR and DRK don't even have unique tools for this new OT niche save for like...Aurora and Oblation.
Leave it to XIV's dev team to make people doom about something that, fundamentally, is as simple as; 'some tanks deal more damage, some tanks have more party mitigation' in execution. Which is already the status quo. A lot of y'all are putting way too much stock into a very, very poor choice of words on CBU3's part. You will not be affected by this in any way.
Last edited by Videra; 07-30-2026 at 09:32 PM.



Yeah that's the part I don't get, people act like we don't already have tanks that are better if targetted and when not.Leave it to XIV's dev team to make people doom about something that, fundamentally, is as simple as; 'some tanks deal more damage, some tanks have more party mitigation' in execution. Which is already the status quo. A lot of y'al arel putting way too much stock into a very, very poor choice of words on CBU3's part. You will not be affected by this in any way.


Problem is its a bit different from them saying some tanks will do more damage and some will have more group mitigation, if that were the case then PLD would be a OT as its been the tank with the most utility for a while.Leave it to XIV's dev team to make people doom about something that, fundamentally, is as simple as; 'some tanks deal more damage, some tanks have more party mitigation' in execution. Which is already the status quo. A lot of y'all are putting way too much stock into a very, very poor choice of words on CBU3's part. You will not be affected by this in any way.
Theirs certainly more to this weird grouping of the roles that you shouldn't just brush off. Otherwise SE wouldn't make some weird offtank main tank split that would likely get backlash.
You do realize the reason they are doing this is simply because Paladin and Bastion have counter attacks….right? If they don’t main tank they will be a damage loss….thats it. That is the only reason they are being dubbed “Main” Tank.
I main gunbreaker, I am not worried about this at all. If a paladin or bastion is in my party I understand they have to be constantly taking damage so they can use their new counter abilities, I accept that and it’s fine….what happens when they die? Instant party wipe? No, I just take over. Armor will still be shared, so defenses will still be the same for all tanks. if two “off” tanks are in the party the content will still be clearable, and more importantly if the off tanks end up being more reliable for damage then the same thing that happened in Heavensward when they tried this exact same concept will repeat itself and paladin and bastion will be left in the dust because they will not be putting out reliable dps.
If you look at the picture you posted it clearly states on the second bullet point that they have actions to “COUNTER” enemy attacks….that is literally the only thing that will make them required to be main tanks. Just watch, when people join raids and they are pared with two main tanks people will dip, because one of them will be basically useless and putting out very low damage because they can’t counter, and tight DPS checks will always fail. Happened back in Heavensward, and Paladin was basically abandoned because of it back then. History is just sadly repeating itself in this case.
|
|
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
|
|
Cookie Policy
This website uses cookies. If you do not wish us to set cookies on your device, please do not use the website. Please read the Square Enix cookies policy for more information. Your use of the website is also subject to the terms in the Square Enix website terms of use and privacy policy and by using the website you are accepting those terms. The Square Enix terms of use, privacy policy and cookies policy can also be found through links at the bottom of the page.

Reply With Quote




