Page 19 of 30 FirstFirst ... 9 17 18 19 20 21 29 ... LastLast
Results 181 to 190 of 409

Hybrid View

  1. #1
    Player
    Terhix's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2021
    Posts
    198
    Character
    Thane Ryder
    World
    Odin
    Main Class
    Dark Knight Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by whiskeybravo View Post
    (...) lead with the bombshell first - Not something you're resurrecting from the grave.
    I mean, have you seen the DRG?

    Folks here are so laser-focused on the tank role split you might be missing the forest for the trees. The main stated goal of Evolved Mode is "Emphasizing Individuality". PLD didn't get anything flashy like Sky High or left/right positionals or a completely different True North, but PLD already has tools no other tank has in Passage (now with an extra heal), Cover (now off-gauge and with buddy dash), Clemency, and its burst being completely ranged.

    OTs are not getting a blanket rotational change like a counter? Fine by me. I don't want DRK, WAR, and GNB to be reskins of one another. Whether they're gonna succeed time will only tell.
    (1)

  2. #2
    Player
    Sazuzaki's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2021
    Location
    Ul'Dah
    Posts
    220
    Character
    Sazu Velgr
    World
    Jenova
    Main Class
    Dark Knight Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by whiskeybravo View Post
    And, I understand they want to keep people on the drip for what they're actually doing, but come on - lead with the bombshell first - Not something you're resurrecting from the grave.
    Full agree there. If you're gonna do a split like that and only show one side, people are bound to be skeptical. But the thing with counters is yes, they have implemented them in the past, and no, it was not a very interesting implementation. But it could've been. XIV's developers tend to 'overcorrect' themselves when one thing happens to be wrong and end up tossing the whole idea out (dark arts). Let's imagine if PLD in 7.0 had Shield Swipe and it gave you an additional 15% mitigation for 10 seconds; you could wait for the boss to auto-attack right before an upcoming tank buster and use it to stack another 15% mit on top of your existing mitigation and become nigh-unkillable. It could've actually rewarded you for good play and mitigating as a tank. I'm hopeful for the new counters because you must time your mitigation to get the full effect, and there's a lot of speculation going on as to what that buff in the showcase might be.
    (0)

  3. #3
    Player
    Mukuku's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2026
    Posts
    63
    Character
    Mukuku Muku
    World
    Spriggan
    Main Class
    Dark Knight Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Sazuzaki View Post
    I understand the concern surrounding it and see it as an open discussion, but I do see a lot of people acting... disingenuous.
    It's more that people are concerned about the game going back to some design decisions that have been proven problematic in the past.

    Counters might have a different implementation than Shield Swipe, but they fundamentally still move back into tying DPS to having aggro. It's the same concept Shield Swipe had and it's bringing exactly the same problem to the table Shield Swipe did.

    In general, I believe coupling DPS to extra stuff leads to a "cursed" game design problem. It's also the reason I am skeptical the devs will find a proper solution: "cursed" game design problems cannot be really "solved", only worked around somehow.
    (2)

  4. #4
    Player
    Sazuzaki's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2021
    Location
    Ul'Dah
    Posts
    220
    Character
    Sazu Velgr
    World
    Jenova
    Main Class
    Dark Knight Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Mukuku View Post
    In general, I believe coupling DPS to extra stuff leads to a "cursed" game design problem. It's also the reason I am skeptical the devs will find a proper solution: "cursed" game design problems cannot be really "solved", only worked around somehow.
    Well it's as you said: job design can only be compromised around. There's no "problematic design" or "correct design," only the design that makes the most people happy.
    (0)

  5. #5
    Player
    Mecia's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2020
    Posts
    453
    Character
    O'ssu Mecia
    World
    Twintania
    Main Class
    Black Mage Lv 100
    I know the split will cause friction with players but also DRK being OT means more HP/MP juggling (delusional)
    (0)

  6. #6
    Player
    Evermomo's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2024
    Posts
    133
    Character
    Illuminant Jewel
    World
    Jenova
    Main Class
    Black Mage Lv 100
    The healer split also works because players effectively have two HP bars; shields that go from 0% to 100%, and HP that goes from 100% to 0%, and each healer moves their own bar in the right direction at the right time, so that's what makes it ideal vs 2 regen or 2 barrier. Tanks don't have that; the boss is either hitting them with something, or it isn't. The difference between MTs and OTs is different than the difference between BH and PH, basically. BH and PH is "this or that," MT and OT is "yes or no."

    (Not saying they can't diversify the tanks in other ways or that they aren't planning to, I'm looking forward to seeing how the defensive profiles play out.)
    (2)

  7. #7
    Player
    Emitans's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2015
    Posts
    424
    Character
    Farinrin Farin
    World
    Balmung
    Main Class
    Pictomancer Lv 100
    The healer split also worked because realistically the only change that happened was AST getting locked into Diurnal Sect. WHM and SCH were the baselines for the Pure and Shield archetypes, so there weren't any changes to healer design needed.
    (1)

  8. #8
    Player
    Carighan's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2018
    Posts
    2,693
    Character
    Carighan Maconar
    World
    Zodiark
    Main Class
    Paladin Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Emitans View Post
    The healer split also worked because realistically the only change that happened was AST getting locked into Diurnal Sect. WHM and SCH were the baselines for the Pure and Shield archetypes, so there weren't any changes to healer design needed.
    This will be different from the tanks being split how exactly?

    (not just meaning you in particular tbh)

    All these excuses seem to focus on "what differences can I find, however meaningless to the underlying idea of splitting a role into two sub-roles?". You're ignoring the core problem with trying to use that to worry about a tank sub-role split: The sub-role split did not meaningfully impact the role as a whole. Regen healers and shield healers are both healers. They heal you. So long as main tanks and offtanks are both tanks, and both tank, this means the split will be a success, yes?

    And now comes a crucial problem: We already have that split. And it doesn't work well right now.

    See, the healer-split was not actually into two sub-roles on a class-level, but on a group-level: It formalized the setup that you want a healer to refill your HP bar, and one to prepare you for the next damage intake. Two healers are more optimized for the former role, and two more for the latter role.
    The incoming tank split entirely emulates this. It formalizes the setup that one tank keeps the boss-attention for 99% of the time, the other is a blue DPS (before you keyboard-warrior, I'll mention the second scenario right below). We already have that setup anyways, in fights such as M11S or M9S just mentioning the recent ones! Right now we could assign any tank to any of the two slots, albeit some tank classes already moderately prefer either of these (e.g. Paladin prefers blue DPS because it allows them to act as normal while also being more free to help out with support and DR if needed, while DRK and WAR prefer MT due to their short invuln-timers coupled with abilities naturally working better if you suffer autoattacks). All the "split" does is formalize the setup.
    In the other tank scenario (this is where we differ from healers!), you have both tanks taking damage consistently. Two current examples are M10S and the Shinryu. Here, tank sub-roles do not matter, and given how we'll be soft-locked into 1 MT + 1 OT anyways in EC, again, they do not matter: Every class gets to tank damage.
    The first scenario is being fully formalizes in EC. Including splitting classes into these two roles. But like I said, this already exists, just not formally. The second scenario, unless they stop using it (a shame, it ought to be used more) makes no distinction, or not much, between the roles so the split doesn't matter, formalized as in EC or not.

    Again I have to ask: So why is this a big deal? You are both tanks, assuming you understand yourself as both tanks right now.
    Are you just happy which schoolyard football team picked you, or well, your class?

    And don't get me wrong, I get that part - to a degree. Because if we want to universally apply this, we also need to allow all healers to pick whether they want to be the regen or the shield healer for this particular fight, and all DPS whether they want to cast spells, fight in melee range or shoot arrows from a distance (essentially), again, for each fight. Either we split roles, or we don't. And there's good reason to do splitting, as the game already has way too much homogenization, and hence splitting into sub-roles (and expecting one of each) allows more differentiation. Which we have way too little. Hence my above comment that in an ideal world tanks would be split into five sub-roles, as in, each tank has a speciality they're better at and something else they're worse at, each is unique. Compare TBC-era WoW tanks where Paladins were the best add-tanks, Druids the best DoT/Magic tanks (with a speciality for Demolocks for 2 particular extremely magic-only fights) and Warriors the best anti-physical tanks.
    Or, alternatively, we don't want such a "This isn't your fight, wrong class!"-setup, in which case we don't want sub-roles. But then why do we accept them for DPS, again? Why are melees different slots than ranged DPS, why can't a Ninja choose to go r2 and fight from range for a fight?
    Or, alternatively, we split into sub-roles but also ensure that each is presence in a fight and accept that hybrid between some differences but also ~equal (doesn't work for damage dealers) representation. Exactly what tanks are now also getting in EC, after damage and healers already have it.
    (1)
    Last edited by Carighan; 05-22-2026 at 03:29 PM.

  9. #9
    Player
    Azurarok's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2022
    Posts
    1,590
    Character
    Medim Azurarok
    World
    Siren
    Main Class
    Machinist Lv 100
    My go to tank's always been WAR and I usually prefer to off tank so this works out for me personally.
    I don't really like the responsibilities of a main tank and also enjoy spot healing and throwing out mits while having to consider more than just 2 buttons to dps.

    Maybe if healers were allowed to be more than whatever they are now things would've been different.
    (1)

  10. #10
    Player
    ReallyMadCow's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2019
    Posts
    5
    Character
    Rex Magne
    World
    Phoenix
    Main Class
    Warrior Lv 100
    Please reconsider splitting tanks into fixed Main Tank and Off Tank roles by job.

    My concern is that this will damage the tank population long-term. There will obviously be huge initial hype around the new tank, but once that settles, the only players likely to feel fully satisfied will be Paladin mains and new tank mains. Warrior, Dark Knight, and Gunbreaker players may feel like their jobs have been officially labelled as “lesser” or secondary tanks, even if that is not the intended message.

    That kind of perception matters. Many tank players enjoy being able to main tank on their preferred job, and being told their job is now naturally an off-tank could push people away from tanking entirely. This could make tank queues worse, especially after the launch hype fades.

    Please consider either giving every tank both Main Tank and Off Tank options through a stance/toggle system, or avoiding fixed MT/OT labels by job altogether.
    (4)
    Hello, why are you reading this. You just wasted 2 seconds of your life.

Page 19 of 30 FirstFirst ... 9 17 18 19 20 21 29 ... LastLast