Page 16 of 30 FirstFirst ... 6 14 15 16 17 18 26 ... LastLast
Results 151 to 160 of 409

Hybrid View

  1. #1
    Player
    Carighan's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2018
    Posts
    2,700
    Character
    Carighan Maconar
    World
    Zodiark
    Main Class
    Paladin Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Lyth View Post
    A more modern game probably wouldn't even implement a trinity design, let alone designate a 'main tank'.
    This is correct, although we can see from Guild Wars 2 that just removing tanks/healers entirely (and by default also removing DPS as a role since it's the only remaining one) does not just solve a problem.

    You still end up with designated main tanks and healers. Even in such a setup!

    And like you say, we already had MT/OT splits. We already had game-decided (not player-decided!) MT and OT splits. In fact we have it right now one could easily argue. Which leads me to ask an important question:
    You call it a "regressive change". But since, right now, on live, we have an MT/OT split, what is the "change"-part of that statement? Just that it re-shuffles who is MT and who is OT?

    (edit)
    And not to misrepresent my opinion, I don't like the idea of some being "the MTs" and some others being "the OTs", I'm merely saying that from all available evidence both in this game and others, it's an unavoidable reality. It - seemingly - cannot be avoided. All SQEX is doing here is adopting the terms and realities the playerbase has already created in the game anyways. The sole meaningful difference is that like with healers, we'll probably see content designed with the idea that you have 1 regen + 1 shield healer, errr, 1 counter + 1 protector tank in your group. Nobody is stopping you from not doing it and in fact by and large the game doesn't even care (see DF group composition results), but the devs won't balance for 2 regen or 2 shield healers any more. It might be fine, it might be optimal, but it's never considered during balancing.

    I really don't see the problem with doing that as the devs. Because again, they're not adding an MT/OT split. It exists. Right now. I dislike the names (heavily), but I also kinda dislike that on the healers, and I get that many don't like lyrical names. Heck we don't even call the red role "damage dealers" any more; we've reduced them to the number you see, DPS. They're not even inventing the terms if we're being honest, they're merely adopting the terms we the playerbase already use ingame. Right now.
    (1)
    Last edited by Carighan; 05-09-2026 at 04:47 PM.

  2. #2
    Player
    Lyth's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2015
    Location
    Meracydia
    Posts
    3,918
    Character
    Lythia Norvaine
    World
    Gilgamesh
    Main Class
    Beastmaster Lv 50
    From my standpoint, I want to see the developers talk us through how they've thought this out, to demonstrate that the potential problems have been evaluated carefully.

    At the moment, the terms MT and OT are just a convention used by guide-makers relating to who takes enmity first in the fight script. It's a bit like saying that you prefer the melee M1 position because you like the west corner more than the east corner. There are differences in how the mechanics play out, but you should be able to do either if you're flexible.

    This is a bit different. Your MT will want to have enmity for as long as possible to maximize their damage output. If there's a forced swap, your MT needs to swap back as soon as possible to get counterattack procs. If the MT is not the active tank, then they will likely be expected to stand in avoidable AoEs to proc their counterattack to avoid 'griefing' their party with lower damage. There will probably be entirely new 'MT uptime' variations to every strat with different swaps once people get their initial clears and want to maximize damage (and you know how well NA/EU PF handles variations in strategy). You will see lots of PF arguments over who gets to tank and for what parts and over how it impacts their personal damage. I don't even need to see that conflict arise to feel disappointed in it.

    And that's in the best case scenario, where MT counterattacks translate into a meaningful damage difference. If they don't, then a lot of groups will deliberately run double OT for the convenience around not having to cater to a MT, and better raidwide mitigation.

    I do think that they need to change things up, but there's no point repeating a design decision that we know doesn't work out from past history. Counterattacks are a great idea, but they should be tied to intercepting specific attacks (i.e. an Interject style move) rather than recieving damage. If you did that, you could even make some tanks proc their counterattacks off of tankbusters, and others off of raidwides. I recognize that they've committed to splitting the tanks, but having an obligate MT that has to take damage is not a good idea. You don't need to 'wait and see' if you played Heavensward and Stormblood. Show me how this time is going to be different.

    If they were really committed to mixing things up for tanks, we'd see an overhaul of the entire defensive toolkit, which has seen a progressive power creep over many expansions.
    (2)

  3. #3
    Player
    Terhix's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2021
    Posts
    198
    Character
    Thane Ryder
    World
    Odin
    Main Class
    Dark Knight Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Lyth View Post
    This is a bit different. Your MT will want to have enmity for as long as possible to maximize their damage output. If there's a forced swap, your MT needs to swap back as soon as possible to get counterattack procs. If the MT is not the active tank, then they will likely be expected to stand in avoidable AoEs to proc their counterattack to avoid 'griefing' their party with lower damage. There will probably be entirely new 'MT uptime' variations to every strat with different swaps once people get their initial clears and want to maximize damage (and you know how well NA/EU PF handles variations in strategy). You will see lots of PF arguments over who gets to tank and for what parts and over how it impacts their personal damage. I don't even need to see that conflict arise to feel disappointed in it.
    Going through the entire Arcadion:

    M1S: there are swaps for busters but you swap back immediately.
    M2S: MT actively tanks the whole fight.
    M3S: 1 swap for a buster by convention.
    M4S: 1 swap for a buster by convention.
    M5S: MT actively tanks the whole fight.
    M6S: desert patch might see MT lose uptime, not an issue with 2x20s gauge.
    M7S: some tether swaps during which MT still takes damage.
    M8S: 1 swap for a buster by convention.
    M9S: MT actively tanks the whole fight.
    M10S: MT actively tanks at least one of the bros.
    M11S: MT actively tanks the whole fight.
    M12S: MT only loses uptime for candies in P2, not an issue with 2x20s gauge.

    12 savage fights, 13 if you count the door boss as a separate thing, and in none of them this would be an issue.

    Ultimates tend to be a bit different, FRU certainly has some moments where depending on strat MT isn't actively tanking, but if you plan strats with Evo tanks in mind those are things that are easy to correct. Ultimates also generally blast the entire raid with damage so frequently you can probably have 2 MTs and still get all your counters in, sans complete downtime (boss not targetable).

    I can see there might be places, especially in Extremes and below, where a tank with counters eats a vuln to get an extra counter in, but this is something that already happens - not for counters but for melee uptime. In EX5 it's a common practice to drop a short CD and eat a vuln during MM1 if it saves you uptime, some guides even recommend it! I'm not going to tell you that taking avoidable damage to do more dps is a good thing to do, but if you are against counters based on the fact that it might incentivize that behavior, you should also be against tanks losing melee uptime since it also incentivizes that behavior. We already had a whole expansion where melees (tanks included) virtually never lost uptime and decided that's bad for the game.
    (1)
    Last edited by Terhix; 05-12-2026 at 06:19 PM. Reason: grammar

  4. #4
    Player
    Mukuku's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2026
    Posts
    63
    Character
    Mukuku Muku
    World
    Spriggan
    Main Class
    Dark Knight Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Terhix View Post
    12 savage fights, 13 if you count the door boss as a separate thing, and in none of them this would be an issue.
    Wouldn't that actually make things worse?

    What is the answer to "DRK/WAR/GBR" which might want to MT or vice-versa? Today there might be a meta but the balance is so close that these players have options. Which options do they have once playing "off-subrole" leads to a significant loss in efficiency?

    Quote Originally Posted by Terhix View Post
    We already had a whole expansion where melees (tanks included) virtually never lost uptime and decided that's bad for the game.
    100% uptime is not bad for the game. Achieving 100% uptime by designing bosses as mostly static with huge hitboxes is bad for the game.

    IMHO players should achieve 100% uptime by proper boss positioning and movement, potentially adding a dimension to encounters and avenue for skill expression.
    (2)

  5. #5
    Player
    Carighan's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2018
    Posts
    2,700
    Character
    Carighan Maconar
    World
    Zodiark
    Main Class
    Paladin Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Mukuku View Post
    Which options do they have once playing "off-subrole" leads to a significant loss in efficiency?
    [citation needed]

    Because the devs have said the difference will be small enough. Which the current differences also are. Which makes me wonder where you even get the idea from.


    Quote Originally Posted by Mukuku View Post
    IMHO players should achieve 100% uptime by proper boss positioning and movement, potentially adding a dimension to encounters and avenue for skill expression.
    So I have two thoughts about that:

    * Okay, that still makes melee DPS as a role conceptually pointless as if they cannot ever lose uptime, that's no different than a caster that never has to cast (also a problem this game has) and is fully mobile.
    * More importantly, do tell how you imagine this'd work.
    (1)

  6. #6
    Player
    Mukuku's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2026
    Posts
    63
    Character
    Mukuku Muku
    World
    Spriggan
    Main Class
    Dark Knight Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Carighan View Post
    [citation needed]

    Because the devs have said the difference will be small enough. Which the current differences also are. Which makes me wonder where you even get the idea from.
    What they stated at the Fan Fest, with emphasis mine:

    High end content, such as Savage and Ultimate parties, these parties will be able to clear these duties far more efficiently by taking advantage of both the main and off role.
    So the difference at the high end of the spectrum will not be "small enough", unless we have a different understanding of what "far more efficiently" means.

    As of low level content, It's true they stated the difference should not matter that much there, but the issue IMHO is the DPS performance being tied to the role.

    A difference in survivability or healing does become irrelevant. Once you can comfortably survive, more survivability/healing becomes basically worthless. A difference in DPS is never irrelevant as more DPS is always desirable even long after you have enough DPS to clear.

    Quote Originally Posted by Carighan View Post
    Okay, that still makes melee DPS as a role conceptually pointless as if they cannot ever lose uptime, that's no different than a caster that never has to cast (also a problem this game has) and is fully mobile.
    What makes you think they cannot lose uptime? That you can achieve 100% uptime does not mean you would get that for free without any skill expression. Dealing with boss positioning and movement is a way to have another dimension and increase the skill expression potential for encounters.

    Quote Originally Posted by Carighan View Post
    More importantly, do tell how you imagine this'd work.
    You can take inspiration from other MMOs to imagine how this could work. In WoW there are plenty of encounters where positioning and moving the boss is very important to optimize how mechanics can be resolved and how damage can be optimized.

    It's a different game with different design, but it doesn't mean FFXIV cannot take some inspiration as they did and still are doing for some aspects of the game.
    (3)
    Last edited by Mukuku; 05-13-2026 at 12:55 AM.

  7. #7
    Player
    Terhix's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2021
    Posts
    198
    Character
    Thane Ryder
    World
    Odin
    Main Class
    Dark Knight Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Mukuku View Post
    Wouldn't that actually make things worse?

    What is the answer to "DRK/WAR/GBR" which might want to MT or vice-versa? Today there might be a meta but the balance is so close that these players have options. Which options do they have once playing "off-subrole" leads to a significant loss in efficiency?
    I've no idea what you're talking about, genuinely. Are you assuming MT will do more dps because they counter? If so, I've a bridge to sell you.
    (0)

  8. #8
    Player
    Mukuku's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2026
    Posts
    63
    Character
    Mukuku Muku
    World
    Spriggan
    Main Class
    Dark Knight Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Terhix View Post
    I've no idea what you're talking about, genuinely. Are you assuming MT will do more dps because they counter? If so, I've a bridge to sell you.
    Except they showed exactly that during the Fan Fest when they showcased PLD? When using Sheltron the PLD did get the buff Surcoat of Satisfaction for 4 seconds and Surcoat of Answer after that for additional 4 seconds. Answering Strike did gets increased potency by blocking damage during Surcoat of Satisfaction. This means countering properly deals more damage than not countering or countering badly.

    Unless you mean "more dps than OTs"? I don't know that, but I know that the devs intend to make using MT/OT "far more efficient" (their words). I don't know how yet, but unless they mess up and fail to achieve their intended design goal you will likely want both and you will likely want both playing in their assigned sub-roles.
    (2)

  9. #9
    Player
    Derio's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2015
    Posts
    3,531
    Character
    Derio Uzumaki
    World
    Sargatanas
    Main Class
    Dark Knight Lv 100
    I think they should have just not presented the slide. They still could have shown PLD but without showing an OT, they have only sowed chaos in the community rather than confidence.

    That or the wording of MT and OT should have been not used.

    After reading some of the JP reviews, many people are happy with the change because one of the biggest problems in JP is there is not a option in the party/group finder to select MT or OT.

    Another thing to note is that PLD defensive kit is still heavily bloated. The only thing they lost was Bulwark but the tradeoff for that is more availability for holy sheltron which isnt bad. If anything PLD defensive kit is overtuned compared to the other tanks which further made the slide confusing because of the MT OT description with PLD current kit satisfying both parts of the slide.

    I think the biggest thing we can hope for is for Berlin to leave us with more answers than questions.
    (2)

  10. #10
    Player
    Carighan's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2018
    Posts
    2,700
    Character
    Carighan Maconar
    World
    Zodiark
    Main Class
    Paladin Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Derio View Post
    I think they should have just not presented the slide. They still could have shown PLD but without showing an OT, they have only sowed chaos in the community rather than confidence.
    Yeah, definitely. Not without being also able to show all tank-setups at least.
    (2)

Page 16 of 30 FirstFirst ... 6 14 15 16 17 18 26 ... LastLast