At that point, why not just remove everything from a jobs kit except for 1 skill each? Anything more complex than that will either be pointless (because it is entirely "optional", it won't be optimal, and so path of least resistance kicks in and the optional part is ignored) or won't meet the criteria for being optional because people will have to think through some quick decision making to find the best outcome in a given situation (also known as, gameplay).
Skill is an integral part of any game; how fast or creatively you can solve a puzzle, how much damage you can do in a short amount of time, seeing whether you can jump over that chasm in a Mario game; and naturally people want to feel rewarded for doing so. If you can't provide people with that higher skill ceiling (and an adequate reward for achieving it), you lose out on replayability and depth, which in turn gets people bored easily, which in turn gets them to leave. "Easy to learn, hard to master" has been a mantra for game designers for a very long time, and is the reason why chess and sports have stood the test of time for millennia.
It doesn't matter if people balk and complain that someone is only using the bare essentials in the kit, as long as it meets the skill floor doing enough DPS for enrage, and the necessary mitigation/healing to live, then anything beyond that is technically optional. This is a community problem, not a game design one, and usually it's more of a problem of perception (people thinking that others are judging their performance) when 99% of the time, they don't care how you play unless it's especially egregious or disruptive.
As for jobs being shunned; we've never been more simplified and homogenized than now, and that still didn't stop PCT being so good for ultimate. As far as I'm concerned, balance issues are not a reason for disregarding some jobs being more simple or more complex than others (personally, I'd rather all jobs have a "simple" rotation that does like 80-90% of the output of an "optimized" rotation, similar to ForsakenRoe in that regard, so that all jobs can be both "simple" and "complex".)



Reply With Quote

