Now we do have kits completely separate and split between pve and pvp which has been the case since SB, which is fortunate because they don't have to dump everything into the same tooltips anymore.
The meta was doing as much damage as possible without losing aggro. This generally meant running content in dps stance and adjusting on aggro with the enmity combos, as seen on most savage bosses for example. Those players tended to apply the same logic in dungeons and tanked all the mobs in dps stance, which allowed to kill them faster, and also didn't really matter anyway because AoE didn't have a split between aggro and dps combo, so the only metric was to actually survive and not shoot your healer in the foot in the process by lacking mitigation. Resource management was a thing, and having multiple variables like doing more damage at the expense of defense would mean potentially losing healer damage and on solo target, losing more dps combos. But on average considering the amount of enmity generated by aggro combos comparatively to tank stances, you'd try and stay in dps stance most of the time, and use tank stance for other things (prog, last resort, adjusting to bad teams, etc). This was actually a source of a lot of skill expression as far as i'm concerned.
In dungeons and normal content though? Totally irrelevant because anybody running in anything could clear a dungeon, and if a tank/healer pair would struggle, then they could fall back to tank stance and no cleric (and that's what most casuals did by default anyway, the tanks in dps stance in dungeons were mostly raiders). All of what it did was offering options for playstyles and for every skill level. Would it still work today with how everybody would hammer to tanks that they NEED to run dungeons in dps stance? I don't honestly know how peer pressure would work there. That's how the changes that have been brought over into the game actually damaged the community, because they only catered to the lowest denominator and removed all options for higher skill levels even in low difficulty content. I call that a big loss personally.
So what? As long as they had fun playing their job fantasy and pressing their buttons, why should it matter? Today too there is huge dps gaps between groups even though everything has been watered down. I can agree that perhaps the size of the gap has diminished but why does it matter? People went through casual content just fine. People weren't dumb either.
I don't think jobs should be designed to be "played by most people correctly". Else with that mentality, just remove anything that's above casual dungeons currently in the game because extreme, savage, ultimate, criterion, aren't designed for most people to clear them either.
More intuitive is good and this game has an atrocious UI and a big onboarding problem in its accessibility. For instance the game never tried to explain the mechanics of jobs in more details to players because the game assumes that everybody has limited intelligence. The real factor is whether or not a player will stop reading and skip, which already happens on tooltips, but assuming that everybody is going to do it and that they should put everybody on the same level by leaving everybody figure things out for themselves is equally dumb, and i'd argue it actually only push players to remain uneducated. Why try go look up guides and do all that homework out of the game if the game doesn't even try? There are a lot of ways to introduce players to the mechanics of a job that don't have to go through the Actions & Trait menu and tooltips. If anything, reading tooltips one by one, making sense of what they say, and trying to put them altogether to see the bigger picture is actually hard work and the tutorial help each job gets is nowhere close enough to what the game should provide.
The irony is found when you look at brainless jobs like SMN or VPR, two of the most recent job designs in the last expansions, and they do in fact have the most complicated Actions & Traits menus to ever grace this game because every button is automated and part of a bigger series of transformations and systems that totally bloat their outdated menus. Comparatively you have the old HW job tooltips that were a LOT simpler, but the jobs could be very esoteric to understand (old BLM, DRK...) and play well, because the game didn't try to explain, again. So, accessibility, ten times yes, because no matter the expansion, jobs have been a nightmare to understand for new players for diverse reasons that have shifted, but not gotten much better. Only the skill ceiling has been lowered (or outright nuked), but the accessibility is still terrible, notably for BLM even throughout the reworks, because what the reworks did was to lower the ceiling, and not to make it more accessible to actually understand and get into.
DRK back in HW was interesting to me because on top of the tank stance and aggro mechanics that as I explained above could create an organic scale of skill expression, DRK also had the Darkside mechanic on top of it, which was very complicated to manage and play well for a lot of casual players. Did this mean casuals shied away from DRK? No, in fact casual DRKs were everywhere, dungeons, story raids, everything, just living the class fantasy. How did they deal with Darkside? They didn't turn it on, or only briefly to access the few skills behind like CnS/Abyssal. And they went through dungeons just fine otherwise. How did the devs react to that for SB? They nuked the MP mechanic behind Darkside and remove a whole bracket of skill specifically addressed to a certain player subset.
I agree but I feel that you're shifting the goalposts here. I merely pointed out that the reason it works in pvp isn't just the lack of script.
This is also why as pointed out by the OP pvp skills are extremely well suited to the deep dungeon model actually, which offers what standard pve doesn't.



Reply With Quote




