
Originally Posted by
Kemiko
The way the Closed Position and Dancer Partner has worked has never changed since it released. The Dance Partner buff does not stack with other instances of the Dance Partner buff. When you use Closed Position on a target, it grants that target the Dance Partner buff. Meaning, two different Dancers using Closed Position on the same target grants the same buff, meaning they do not stack.
When you use Closed Position on a target, it grants the buff Closed Position to yourself, which is a completely different buff. It's because of this that two Dancers can used Closed Position on each other, because they both end up with 1 instance of Closed Position buff and 1 instance of Dance Partner buff. They're different buffs. That's why they stack.
And since Dancer's release, people have been absolutely terrible at understanding this despite the job quest straight up telling you exactly this.
EDIT: To remain on topic with the thread, I generally give Dance Partner to whoever's doing the most damage or whoever I can trust won't get themselves killed and waste my buff. Though, absolutely, if someone demands it, or is rude, they just don't get it. Doesn't matter if the content is casual or not.
More often than not, though, I have to remind other Dancers to use the Closed Position ability at all. I don't care what the content itself is, or how hard or easy someone thinks it is, I'd appreciate people at least playing the job they selected at least somewhat properly.