Not enough activity

[Kaurhz]

They would solve a lot of problems if the Moogle Treasure Trove came earlier in the patch with increased variety of rewards, and had a longer cycle behind it.

[BigCheez]

They would solve a lot of problems if the Moogle Treasure Trove came earlier in the patch with increased variety of rewards, and had a longer cycle behind it.

Something like Moogle Treasure Trove but with new, unique rewards is actually a really good idea. Moogle Treasure Trove is cool but I generally have everything that you can get from it and there's no point in engaging with it beyond grabbing a few of the treasure maps with guaranteed portals.

It would be good if it was running all the time, to avoid preying on FOMO, and they could just switch the activities associated with it around every month or so to keep it fresh, and add a few new rewards every patch.

That's actually the way. People who can't let go of the game (any game) and expect it to be entertaining all the time forever are always going to be disappointed, because that's an unrealistic expectation. Is FFXIV perfect? No. Could it be better? Certainly. But no game will ever exist that can be fun forever and ever.

I don't think anyone expects infinite content. The problem is that right now, most people are done with a new patch in a couple of days and then stuck waiting for the next patch for 4 months. Worse yet, they drip feed each patch so that x.1, x.15 and x.16 are spread just far enough apart that you need to pay for 2 months to play each wafer-thin slice of content.

[YumieYumiki]

I don't think anyone expects infinite content. The problem is that right now, most people are done with a new patch in a couple of days and then stuck waiting for the next patch for 4 months. Worse yet, they drip feed each patch so that x.1, x.15 and x.16 are spread just far enough apart that you need to pay for 2 months to play each wafer-thin slice of content.

You don't have to play the content as soon as it's released, you can wait a few months and do it all at once.