Quote Originally Posted by Collin_Sky View Post
Are you seriously confused about how I can dislike the design of the 24 man content but still want more gearing options? These are two completely separate things.

I don't care where the gear comes from, as long as there are more max item level options to choose from. Before Chaotic gear, healer BiS was 727, which was awful. With the addition of Chaotic gear, healer BiS is now 730. It's the same for tanks - I've been able to drop tenacity on the body piece in favor of a more useful stat.

More gearing options are beneficial and healthy for players who care about optimizing their performance. There's no reason to be against this.
Putting the very best gear in bad, unpopular content makes no sense. If anything, it's decreasing the chances of improvement in said content, as more people will be playing it despite complaining, and despite it being released on Christmas day. This is why Chaotic gear should be at best the same thing as Savage, until they figure out if the community likes it or not.

One can be in favor of more gearing options while also wanting Chaotic to have the same substats as Savage, or worse. It's pretty simple. In my opinion, Chaotic gear should be in normal content that has been popular for years, the 24-man Alliances, which were always 10 ilvls behind 8-man Savage for no reason.