/r/ffxivdiscussion: Should the endgame Tomestone cap accumulate each week?

[BigCheez]

There is no "difficulty" or "value" in timelocks, they aren't even time consuming, playing 20 minutes per day for 5 days of the week in Expert Roulette is all it takes like you said yourself, what this thread is asking is to not punish someone for coming in later into a tier and effectively miss out on thousands on Tomes they can never get back while they are relevant.

Look at it this way, is there any meaningful difficulty difference in clearing a Savage tier 8 times in a row, or 8 times spaced across 8 weeks? you did the same actions, there was just some arbitrary time gate.

Without timegating there would be horrendous expectations placed on players. Want to do M2S? I hope you farmed M1 until you got all your gear from it first, repeat until end of tier. This would suck all the fun out of week 1 raiding.

[VeyaAkemi]

Without timegating there would be horrendous expectations placed on players. Want to do M2S? I hope you farmed M1 until you got all your gear from it first, repeat until end of tier. This would suck all the fun out of week 1 raiding.

This is not what this thread is asking though. They are asking to make the cap cumulative, so that it is 450 week 1, 900 week 2, 1350 week 3, 1800 week 4, ad infinitum, as a way to not punish someone for being unable to play a week or two, not to remove the cap entirely, I was simply addressing the point that dpsguy was trying to imply the timegates create difficulty in any way.

This wouldn't in any way create higher expectations of players, but it would remove the element of tome caps feeling like "be there or be square" at times.

[BigCheez]

This is not what this thread is asking though. They are asking to make the cap cumulative, so that it is 450 week 1, 900 week 2, 1350 week 3, 1800 week 4, ad infinitum, as a way to not punish someone for being unable to play a week or two, not to remove the cap entirely, I was simply addressing the point that dpsguy was trying to imply the timegates create difficulty in any way.

This wouldn't in any way create higher expectations of players, but it would remove the element of tome caps feeling like "be there or be square" at times.

Oh, that sounds great. Can't wait to run expert roulette 25 times before I can start raiding on week 2.

[IOwn92FCHouses]

Oh, that sounds great. Can't wait to run expert roulette 25 times before I can start raiding on week 2.

Presumably, you'd be capping each week normally since you'd be actively playing, just as you already do now. You'd only have to run expert 25 times if you wanted.

This is the 2nd disingenuous comment now. Because no week 1 group will waste time reclearing a fight for gear when you can use that time for progging the next fight, and you know that.

What's your problem?

[BigCheez]

Presumably, you'd be capping each week normally since you'd be actively playing, just as you already do now. You'd only have to run expert 25 times if you wanted.

This is the 2nd disingenuous comment now. Because no week 1 group will waste time reclearing a fight for gear when you can use that time for progging the next fight, and you know that.

What's your problem?

The expectation is generally that you have capped tomes in advance of raid and bought any upgrades that you can before raiding on week 2. This would definitely make that more painful.

The perceived problem is not solved by creating an ever expanding hamster wheel tome grind. They just need to add additional sources of equivalent gear that people can use to quickly gear off jobs later in a patch cycle.

As per my other response, a much better solution would be to release criterion a month or so after savage and have that drop augmented tome equivalent gear. Then you can use that to gear off jobs.

The current time to BiS isn't an issue at all.

[IOwn92FCHouses]

The expectation is generally that you have capped tomes in advance of raid and bought any upgrades that you can before raiding on week 2. This would definitely make that more painful.

You cap in between raid times on week 1, week 2, etc. You know, like we've always done. And, if tomes drop before the raid does? You cap for those weeks like normal. This suggested change changes nothing for you.

Speaking of painful... That last minute week 2 clear, amiright? Maybe that's why you're under the false impression that there would be a ton of extra farming to do for a suggested change that would be a mechanic used to catch up/prevent progress loss.

[BigCheez]

You cap in between raid times on week 1, week 2, etc. You know, like we've always done. And, if tomes drop before the raid does? You cap for those weeks like normal. This suggested change changes nothing for you.

Speaking of painful... That last minute week 2 clear, amiright? Maybe that's why you're under the false impression that there would be a ton of extra farming to do for a suggested change that would be a mechanic used to catch up/prevent progress loss.

Who does this?

You cap tomes before raid so you have your tome gear for raid. You need to raid on Tuesday because if you wait until Wednesday or later, there are only droolers left in PF.