Results 1 to 10 of 90

Hybrid View

  1. #1
    Player
    Rekin's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2013
    Location
    Ul'Dah
    Posts
    6
    Character
    Rekin Evole
    World
    Midgardsormr
    Main Class
    Warrior Lv 91
    The patch is about a 7/10.
    MSQ:
    The overall story is fine. Follow up on death of Solution Nine's monarch leads to their entire society feeling uneasy about the future.
    I feel our ability to at least say it's inappropriate for us to be there is a positive step in the right direction compared to our dialogue choices in 7.0.

    "Not Texas" segment felt weak. Koana's "heroic" defense cutscene should have been done differently and it feels like the scene was a combination of either the writers relying on Japanese Cliches or just budget cuts.
    To elaborate: Koana is an intellectual with bouts of passion, when running to the defense of the lone cow I thought the part of him shooting the dino was fine up until he he tried to block the charge. The scene could have been cooler and still had the same point if when he reached the cow he did the mch's heavy arms thing and unloaded on the beast and in the resulting dust cloud it still could charge through and hit him.
    What this changes is makes him appear less idiotic while still getting what the devs wanted to convey thematically through the action of defending the cow.

    Another problem with that particular scene is how is he outrunning Wuk and the WoL(assuming to be a melee job). Wuk should outpace him easily and intercept the trex first to get nosale'd which then reasonably makes sense for him to be in a position to stand in front of the cow and do his speech.

    The Zoraal Ja freakout is pretty good. The man has more daddy issues than all the primarches from 40k combined. I wish that was given more time and attention in 7.0.

    Deathcult following not-Sphene is a nice turn of events. I hope it's not wrapped up in one patch and given time to breathe and grow into something bigger for at least 3 patches.

    Overall I feel the writers are incapable of writing scenes that allow multiple moving parts given how stiff the "action" parts are. There is no believable situation where you have multiple hyper-competent martial masters not be able to react to surprise events. Anyone who has played Monster hunter knows even a bunch of idiots are able to react when a Rajang shows up.
    At one point or another the writers are going to have to figure out how to explain why things happen in the manner they do that makes actual sense.



    24-Man

    As a FFXI Vet who left during the last expansion I love all the references and I love seeing Prishe do exactly what I expected her to do. The bosses were great each one better than the last. As a massive fan of the Ark Angels fight in FFXI I loved how they handled it here it was the best.

    I'm not too fond of Sareel Ja being a thing. I highly suspect he isn't the true villain. It would be very cool if instead, they played on FFXI's long theme of Odin being the one pulling the strings again. I was upset when Prishe went off with the FFXI adventurer stand in and didn't invite the WoL. I hope they give us a wind-up minion at least later.
    (1)

  2. #2
    Player
    EdwinLi's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2013
    Posts
    4,887
    Character
    Edwin Li
    World
    Balmung
    Main Class
    Machinist Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Rekin View Post
    The patch is about a 7/10.


    24-Man

    As a FFXI Vet who left during the last expansion I love all the references and I love seeing Prishe do exactly what I expected her to do. The bosses were great each one better than the last. As a massive fan of the Ark Angels fight in FFXI I loved how they handled it here it was the best.

    I'm not too fond of Sareel Ja being a thing. I highly suspect he isn't the true villain. It would be very cool if instead, they played on FFXI's long theme of Odin being the one pulling the strings again. I was upset when Prishe went off with the FFXI adventurer stand in and didn't invite the WoL. I hope they give us a wind-up minion at least later.
    A little detail other players are finding with this FFXI raid is that once players complete it...


    Alxaal and Prishe can be found in the open world at random locations since they are now traveling the world as Adventurers. It seems they may become permenant side characters that wander the world with this Raid storyline. Their group may even expand each raid section if new characters are planned to be introduced to their group.

    This will be a nice touch to this raid if it adds the FFXI adventurer group into the world of FF14.
    (3)

  3. #3
    Player
    Iscah's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2017
    Posts
    14,096
    Character
    Aurelie Moonsong
    World
    Bismarck
    Main Class
    Summoner Lv 90
    The computer ate my notes so hopefully I haven't forgotten anything particularly interesting that I wrote down the first time...

    General MSQ

    The name Kanilokka caught my attention for unintended reasons because it had previously been used, rather oddly, for a Mamool Ja at the Landsguard headquarters in Tuliyollal and I wasn't sure whether that was an error or trying to make a point of the city being multicultural.

    I spent the dungeon wondering whether there was any significance (not that the timing would have added up) but having checked again now, he's been renamed more conventionally as Gavoll Ja so it was indeed an error. I wonder if they made the 7.1 character first and then realised their error, or if they found the error first and decided to reuse the name.

    ---

    The dungeon gear is very pretty (I scored the fending dress on my trust run) but so completely disconnected from the aesthetic of the dungeon. I guess it's something that got dumped there from Old Alexandria when the shards merged?

    Also the NPC outfits explain why we got that scientist glamour outfit recently.

    ---

    There seem to be people still alive and not-zombified in the lab vats and nobody even commented on it.

    ---

    Weather in the final section of the dungeon is variable but often strangely clear - the weather type says "electrostatic dust" but still, actual sunlight seems to be getting through, and we must still be inside the dome or there wouldn't have been a point to building Vanguard if Zoraal Ja already had access to a facility that led outside it.

    Is earth aether able to nullify the constant storm?

    ---

    I was expecting the Lupipyati to turn out to have a human mind embedded, but later I got the impression that Zoraal Ja might have been planning to take it over himself once the research was perfected, and it was being kept sealed away until that was ready. On second thought I'm not sure that's in character for him (we still learned basically nothing further about him) but perhaps it could be for a loyal follower.

    I've since seen other people theorising that Teeshal Ja might have been embedded in it, but I don't think that seems right. It could be a conclusion they intended to imply, but it doesn't feel like things add up to that, when it happened after Zoraal Ja rejected her.

    My overall impression is that something catastrophic happened to the facility on the day that she left baby Gulool Ja hidden, which resulted in the ruined state of the facility. (Specifically, Shale says "some manner of accident happened at the facility after this was recorded".) I suppose that could have been waking up the Lupipyati to force her mind into it, and soon after she went mad and rampaged, but then who would be left to seal the beast back up again? Kanilokka seems to be the only one left who is still competent, but it doesn't seem like a one-man job.

    Also I have to wonder what the soul-transferral process would do in term of the whole Living Memory / regulator system. It seems that memories of Teeshal Ja have been erased, which implies that she died with regulator active, but would soul transferral register as death?

    ---

    We still haven't had any direct indication of Gulool Ja's age, but the closest is that "people lived [in Yuweyawata] until nearly a decade ago" which could be the date of the lab accident.

    Previously I'd decided to assume he's nine years old based on Vivi's age in FFIX, which conveniently adds up, whether correct or not.

    ---

    Koana's history felt too dramatic - not just a tragic accident but his parents are specially heroic.

    Also, while it's lovely he's found this "the hhetso are sacred" creed, I never got the impression that's actually the Hhetsarro mindset on this front? They follow the herds but they still use the rroneek for hides and meat, unless they're exclusively taking the ones that died of other causes.

    (Kind of awkward that they give roast rroneek as one of the reward options for the quest if they don't actually eat them...)


    MSQ conclusion implications

    So, "Neo Sphene" says the plan is to rapture 5000 citizens into Living Memory 2.0, but is this actually her plan (or the plan of whoever is behind this) or is there just some reason to make the citizens think it's happening?

    What's the plan? Who benefits? It has the reek of Ascian operations but that feels too simple an answer.

    Meanwhile, if we assume the other girl in Living Memory is the "true Sphene" - Endless but freed from the system admin AI's conflicting goals - what has caused her to spawn here and now, not earlier? Has something been switched back on, or has she been driven out of some place where her data was in storage? (The crown, or something else?)

    Random detail but from what we can see, she's not wearing her gloves when we see her hand, so has probably spawned, well, not in her queenly robes...

    Also, the Duskwight attendant had better be an innocent victim in all this and not the one pulling the strings.



    PS. I succeeded in overflowing the key items page. Nothing exciting happens, you just lose sight of the last couple of items in the list.
    (6)
    Last edited by Iscah; 11-17-2024 at 10:23 PM.

  4. #4
    Player
    Turnintino's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2022
    Location
    Radz-at-Han
    Posts
    422
    Character
    R'vhen Tia
    World
    Excalibur
    Main Class
    Dancer Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Iscah View Post
    Also, while it's lovely he's found this "the hhetso are sacred" creed, I never got the impression that's actually the Hhetsarro mindset on this front? They follow the herds but they still use the rroneek for hides and meat, unless they're exclusively taking the ones that died of other causes.

    (Kind of awkward that they give roast rroneek as one of the reward options for the quest if they don't actually eat them...)
    I have to single this out because I had the same thought lol.
    Particularly when the WoL was given the opportunity to compare them to family (obviously to appeal to Koana's principles, but nevertheless). I was like, "Well, traditionally, we don't cannibalize our family, but okay..."
    (2)
    Last edited by Turnintino; 11-18-2024 at 05:03 PM. Reason: Realized a little too late that I broke Iscah's spoiler tag lol

  5. #5
    Player
    PorxiesRCute's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2021
    Location
    Gridania
    Posts
    349
    Character
    Nekhii Qestir
    World
    Kraken
    Main Class
    Botanist Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Iscah View Post
    Also, while it's lovely he's found this "the hhetso are sacred" creed, I never got the impression that's actually the Hhetsarro mindset on this front? They follow the herds but they still use the rroneek for hides and meat, unless they're exclusively taking the ones that died of other causes.

    (Kind of awkward that they give roast rroneek as one of the reward options for the quest if they don't actually eat them...)
    This was actually the most realistic part to me! Think about how many people say they love animals and then turn around and eat them.
    (0)

  6. #6
    Player
    Iscah's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2017
    Posts
    14,096
    Character
    Aurelie Moonsong
    World
    Bismarck
    Main Class
    Summoner Lv 90
    Quote Originally Posted by PorxiesRCute View Post
    This was actually the most realistic part to me! Think about how many people say they love animals and then turn around and eat them.
    That's not really comparable.

    In any case it's not inherently hypocritical to "love animals" but also use some individual animals as sustenance (so long as those animals are well cared for), but specifically for the Hhetsarro, what we know is that they treat the movement of the rroneek herds as a guide for their own movements while also at least occasionally killing individual rroneek for necessary resources.

    For a tribe that treats this ebb and flow of nature as the guide to their lives, having a natural predator take a single rroneek is something I would have expected is maybe a little sad to them but not something that needs to be prevented.

    It would have been kind of interesting if Koana did all his heroics and then the chief was like, "well, we did need to kill the deadly apex predator heading towards the village, but we do let nature take its course for things like that" and it became a further learning moment for Koana instead of him getting a single revelation of the whole philosophy in one go.
    (3)

  7. #7
    Player
    SannaR's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2018
    Posts
    3,320
    Character
    Sanna Rosewood
    World
    Midgardsormr
    Main Class
    White Mage Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by EdwinLi View Post
    A little detail other players are finding with this FFXI raid is that once players complete it...


    Alxaal and Prishe can be found in the open world at random locations since they are now traveling the world as Adventurers. It seems they may become permenant side characters that wander the world with this Raid storyline. Their group may even expand each raid section if new characters are planned to be introduced to their group.

    This will be a nice touch to this raid if it adds the FFXI adventurer group into the world of FF14.
    About that

    They seem to only appear in Tuliyollal, in Earthenshire and right outside of Worlar's Echo. I looked for them Shaaloani but didn't find them anywhere near where npcs are. So I don't think they're in Xak Tural.


    @Cleretic about Prishe

    Everyone in Tavnazia would know about her. Maybe not what she looks like as she unfortunately was given the moniker "the abhorrent one". All due to her being cursed early in life in an unknown amount of time prior to present day. Her curse gave her immortality and stopped her growth. She is one of three children/teens in XI that are way older than they appear to be.


    @Rosenstrauch

    About Sphene's aid

    If you go and talk to him after the initial funeral cutscene he says something about wishing he had her majesty's resolve. Which at the time I didn't really afford any attention to, but after the end of the patch I'm having 2nd thoughts about. Did he cave so hard in his grief that he went and did something he didn't understand fully what it would do or is he just as much of a victim? As this feels something Preservation would do. I still wondering why we didn't get to meet them til now.


    @Iscah about earth ather I would have to say yes if the information we learn about the elements are correct.
    In Eureka we learn that earth grounds lighting. So it would make some sense as to why we are able to see the sun.


    About the rroneek I feel they're going with how many tribes of the Great Planes region of America regard the buffalo as a sacred animal that they also occasionally hunt and use all parts from.
    (1)
    Last edited by SannaR; 11-18-2024 at 12:19 AM.