Page 8 of 9 FirstFirst ... 6 7 8 9 LastLast
Results 71 to 80 of 89
  1. #71
    Player
    Cleretic's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2021
    Location
    Solution Eight (it's not as good)
    Posts
    2,971
    Character
    Ein Dose
    World
    Mateus
    Main Class
    Alchemist Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Iscah View Post
    Did the "basically finished" rank-up quest for the Pelupelu travel agency...

    What was the point of this whole quest line? At the beginning it felt like it was being set up to deliver large amounts of random worldbuilding details but it just dried up entirely after a couple of quests. After that there were tours going on but we never got to hear anything of it. It also really needs more daily quests, or more variety within the quests at least, instead of handing out all our flyers to the same three people for the fifth time.

    Also, Liplu felt entirely interchangeable from all the other Pelupelu we've previously met. And I hated the repeated coin-jangling sound effect, like rubbing it in our faces that it all comes back to making profit for someone, even if every single person in the region is conveniently happy to support it.
    I feel like the Pelupelu society quest is almost a modern attempt at what earlier society questlines are like; it's something comparable to the Vath or Ixal questline in content, but told in a way that reflects what they've learned in structuring and building up those questlines from stories like the Omicrons.

    Unfortunately, it has a problem from some other early society quests: not having a whole lot of point to it. It needs some raised stakes, even if it's just more established consequences for failure.

    EDIT: I will say, though, the actual society area that gets upgraded over time might be the best one yet. I could see that becoming a solid roleplay hangout even with the barrier for entry.
    (3)
    Last edited by Cleretic; 12-02-2024 at 07:50 PM.

  2. #72
    Player
    Fenral's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2011
    Posts
    2,175
    Character
    W'fharl Tia
    World
    Gilgamesh
    Main Class
    Viper Lv 100
    I am still following the discussion in this thread, but I finished the MSQ a week ago and didn't really have anything to say that hasn't already been said. I'll give it a go anyway.

    MSQ



    -_____________________-




    A lot happened, and not a lot? I was hoping for Shepetto and Koana to meet, but everyone gets over hangups so quickly these days it's like any potential conflict was over before they actually met. It felt like a checklist item rather than a meaningful episode for, well, anyone actually.

    The stuff with Gulool Ja's mother was just gross all around. Like, I'm glad she wasn't some impossibly pure doomed mother figure, but Ju-heee-zus. Big "extorting the sperm donor for childcare money" energy from that one. "Here, kid, turns out both your parents were just awful self-absorbed people and neither of them cared about you as a person at all." Oof.

    And now we have Ascian(?!?)Sphene running around, but also Real(!?!)Sphene in play as well?(!?) It seems like the basic plan isn't actually to pick 5000 souls to save, but to seed a conflict among the Alexandrians to demonstrate to somebody (possibly us) that humans are all selfish bastards who are only in it for themselves and their immediate circle. Like, no duh?

    It honestly wouldn't be a bad idea on paper, but aside from a few comically evil goons, everyone in this expansion has just been so perfectly perfect that the seed isn't really there in the current material, and it's only justified at all by DT's existence in continuity with ARR and Shadowbringers. I just can't see the current expac's citizenry escalating things to the extent that would make a compelling .3 patch. I'm sure everyone already knows the correct lesson to be learned here and just needs a single conveniently-timed speech to return to correct moral behavior. (To be fair to DT, XIV's writing already showed shades of this when Nanamo pulled an Aesop out of her hat in the conference with Varis back in Stormblood's patch cycle, but there it actually felt somewhat incisive.)

    With memory manipulation in play, I found myself longing for a bigger, more ambitious twist to address the glaring tonal incongruity between Dawntrail and the earlier saga. What if our memories are wrong? Maybe DT felt so uncannily lighthearted and relatively low on consequence because we were made to forget all the bad stuff that actually happened? Maybe Valigarmanda razed a village or two before we brought it down? Maybe people died helping us during the contest who we don't even remember? Obviously there are all sorts of meta reasons that can't happen, but I wish I didn't spend most of the story wishing it understood how to effectively utilize the tools it gave itself.
    (3)
    あっきれた。

  3. #73
    Player
    SannaR's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2018
    Posts
    3,320
    Character
    Sanna Rosewood
    World
    Midgardsormr
    Main Class
    White Mage Lv 100
    I feel that the society story was meant to be a huge let's recover from the huge storm that's been attributed to Valigatmanda's prison weakening for the most part. Yet during the MSQ the havoc it wrought was treated as some mild inconvenience. Only to go hard on the Pelu Pelu belief that one can only find happiness from striking a deal that benefits both parties. So of course everyone is fine with it all.
    (0)

  4. #74
    Player
    Dastan's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2023
    Posts
    57
    Character
    Dastan Twillane
    World
    Leviathan
    Main Class
    Paladin Lv 100
    My thoughts on the 7.1 MSQ:

    I thought the ending of it was a fantastic setup for the next patch. The rest of the patch was like "Okay, now we know." We now know the missing answers of both Koana's and Galool Ja's parents. Yes, they could have easily put this into the 7.0 MSQ, but they didn't and it had to be answered otherwise people would have that lingering thought and wonder if it's important. Now we know it isn't really. It just had to be answered lol.

    Sphene returning isn't really surprising if we paid attention to the story. We have heard of this shadowy organization called Preservation a few times in the 7.0 MSQ. The Neo-Regulators are obviously flawed from the get, and the artificial scarcity of only 5000 being available for distribution is intended to cause panic among the Alexandrians, who are completely in fear of dying and will desperately try to seek the comfort of not having to worry about it, IE becoming an Endless. We know this means the slaughter of the population and a preservation of their memories in the Cloud. This facsimile of Sphene is a reset version that doesn't have the memories of us or Wuk Lamat. It's the version that worked with Zoraal Ja initially, only a tad bit more insane. The upgrade lol. Preservation is obviously behind this as well, and their goal seemingly for now is to control the population of Solution Nine, and the rest of the Star as well now that they have a gateway to the Source directly. My guess is that these Neo-Regulators are not going to turn people into Endless as we know them, but something more akin to a grotesque monster akin to Sin Eaters/Blasphemies as they lose their souls and their memories warp into an amalgamation of fearful thoughts.


    Next patch is shaping up to be insane. x.1 patches have always been the initial setup before the climax of the post story. We'll see what they got. I say let em cook and see what happens. I know people have been very polarizing on this story so far, but I really enjoy it and the implications at play here.
    (2)

  5. #75
    Player
    Cleretic's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2021
    Location
    Solution Eight (it's not as good)
    Posts
    2,971
    Character
    Ein Dose
    World
    Mateus
    Main Class
    Alchemist Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Dastan View Post
    My thoughts on the 7.1 MSQ:

    I thought the ending of it was a fantastic setup for the next patch. The rest of the patch was like "Okay, now we know." We now know the missing answers of both Koana's and Galool Ja's parents. Yes, they could have easily put this into the 7.0 MSQ, but they didn't and it had to be answered otherwise people would have that lingering thought and wonder if it's important. Now we know it isn't really. It just had to be answered lol.
    A bit of my own thoughts on the 'importance' of those first parts, because I don't think you're wrong, but I do think it's a little more complex.

    I think it's interesting in seeing how these two character reveals specifically feel in 'importance'. Because Koana's isn't narratively important, but was deeply personally important; a huge amount of his personal journey came from his relationship to his perception of tradition, and his hatred of what he thought was a culture that left him to die because 'that's just what they do'. If we pick apart Koana's journey as a person in retrospect, I feel like this patch will be the moment for him, that greatly changes how his life goes. ...but Koana and his parents aren't actually important to the core story of the expansion, so as big a character moment as it is for him, it really does feel like it was just necessary cleanup that we had to get to eventually.

    Gulool Ja's mom on the other hand I think is exactly the opposite: almost the entire reason Gulool Ja wants to look into this is because it doesn't matter to him, and he feels like it should, like he owes it to his mom to have feelings about her. I don't honestly feel like that part is different afterwards, but I highly suspect this isn't the last we'll hear about Teeshal Ja. This is just predictions and vibes going, but I think that once the book's closed on Dawntrail's patches this will probably be looked back on as a big deal, in a similar way to the first appearance of Fandaniel in 5.1.
    (4)

  6. #76
    Player
    Iscah's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2017
    Posts
    14,070
    Character
    Aurelie Moonsong
    World
    Bismarck
    Main Class
    Summoner Lv 90
    I had been looking forward to Nitonikwe's delivery questline thinking there would probably be an interesting story to tell, but it just seems completely devoid of anything besides a single plot point dropped in the intro quest and then basic tasks each week. "We're fixing the train. We need components. We need maps. We need tools."

    Meanwhile it leaves me wondering what the heck is going on with Vanguard -- or rather, the two country governments for which Vanguard is the sole border crossing -- that confused passengers are left to wander the facility alone, with or without a paper map to help them find their way through. At bare minimum we should be providing bollards and signposts rather than map-making supplies, but really this seems like something that should be a concern for higher agencies than the railroad company.
    (3)

  7. #77
    Player
    Cleretic's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2021
    Location
    Solution Eight (it's not as good)
    Posts
    2,971
    Character
    Ein Dose
    World
    Mateus
    Main Class
    Alchemist Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Iscah View Post
    Meanwhile it leaves me wondering what the heck is going on with Vanguard -- or rather, the two country governments for which Vanguard is the sole border crossing -- that confused passengers are left to wander the facility alone, with or without a paper map to help them find their way through. At bare minimum we should be providing bollards and signposts rather than map-making supplies, but really this seems like something that should be a concern for higher agencies than the railroad company.
    We know from the 7.1 story that the actual border between Tural and Alexandria is a little muddy; Yyasulani in particular is mentioned as a debate point, but reasonably speaking the entire region between there and the 'start' of the dome probably is. Which makes a lot of sense; as an external audience we look at that firm dividing line of Vanguard and the dome and probably go 'this side is Tural, this side is Alexandria', but as nations... no, that's genuinely a really hard question to answer, and I'm not surprised that it falls into a weird ambiguous zone where neither government is willing to do it. After all, if Tural lays those tracks, does that read as a political declaration of territory? A private railroad company, if nothing else, has a claim of neutrality that both sides appear to respect.

    And that's all with an assumption that either nation has a concept of publicly owned/maintained transport routes in the first place, which might well not be true. Both sides have bridges, but that's about it.

    I'm also a faint bit disappointed with Nitonikwe's storyline, I'd love more on this, or their marriage, or Xbr'aal women in their culture, but being honest, custom delivery questlines are rarely big story mines anyway; only Anden and Margrat really pulled it off, they're definitely exceptions (and Anden's was actually back-loaded, we could still have room for that sort of end quest). It's more of a 'this could've been exceptional' disappointment rather than a 'you're falling below the bar' disappointment.
    (4)
    Last edited by Cleretic; 01-02-2025 at 05:54 PM.

  8. #78
    Player
    Mchappy's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2015
    Location
    Ul'dah
    Posts
    39
    Character
    Mick Gaoxing
    World
    Midgardsormr
    Main Class
    Pictomancer Lv 100
    Patch 7.1 MSQ

    I am really looking forward to seeing where we are going with Sphene's storyline, personally. Although it has gotten rather repetitive, part of me is hoping that there is some sort of Ascian tie-in here that will explain the events of that ending. It seems to ring similarly to a particular Shadowbringer patch cycle with Elidibus. I get that Dawntrail is supposed to be a vacation for the Warrior of Light; however, I felt that the story was almost too disconnected from the rest of the world that we've been building up for a decade now. I can only take so many "death-rebirth" story tropes.

    Before Dawntrail released, I recall seeing the mask on Sphene's character design on her waist. Therefore, I am still holding out for hope that there is some Ascian connection here that will turn the story on its head, or make it feel more personable to the Warrior of Light. Right now, I am just a casual observer to be used as Wuk Lamat's fighting tool. I want to feel more connected moving forward.
    (0)
    :・゚✧:・.☽˚。・゚✧:・.:

  9. #79
    Player
    Cleretic's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2021
    Location
    Solution Eight (it's not as good)
    Posts
    2,971
    Character
    Ein Dose
    World
    Mateus
    Main Class
    Alchemist Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Mchappy View Post
    Patch 7.1 MSQ

    Before Dawntrail released, I recall seeing the mask on Sphene's character design on her waist. Therefore, I am still holding out for hope that there is some Ascian connection here that will turn the story on its head, or make it feel more personable to the Warrior of Light. Right now, I am just a casual observer to be used as Wuk Lamat's fighting tool. I want to feel more connected moving forward.
    I hate to rain on your parade, but the thing you're talking about isn't the thing you think it is.

    The ornament on Sphene's hip isn't a mask, and would be a pretty uncomfortable one if it was. It's the symbol of the Endless; it's Alexandria's emblem as seen across both the Solution Nine administrative building and Otis' shield, with an infinity symbol tacked on. From a design perspective it's got some interesting extra shades to it; that infinity symbol actually clashes with the Alexandrian emblem in a way that makes it look like an after-the-fact addition, and not one that's actually caring about integration with the original symbol, which sounds about right for a personification of the Endless system.

    And frankly, it never looked like an Ascian sigil in the first place.

    And is an Ascian actually a meaningful threat enough to get you invested on their own merits anyway? Their central decision-makers and means of prolonging themselves died in Shadowbringers, and the central object of their planning died in Endwalker. Sure there's somewhere between two to five Ascians plausibly still alive, depending on how good you think Gaius and the Students of Baldesion are at killing them, but are they actually a threat when they can't enact their goals? Do they even care anymore without Emet, Elidibus and Lahabrea leading them? Fandaniel sure didn't.

    Personally, I'd far more engaged with the threat we're probably actually looking at: Preservation. A big question mark to be sure, but all evidence suggests that they're probably still around, and probably have as much access to their core tools as they ever had; whatever they want to do, they're eminently capable of doing it. All it requires is that you care about the people they're threatening--and you already should, they're as much people as anyone else we've met.
    (2)

  10. #80
    Player Kuroka's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2016
    Location
    Limsa
    Posts
    3,702
    Character
    Ulala Ula
    World
    Shiva
    Main Class
    Reaper Lv 90
    About the Ascian remains, do we know if they only kept one active shard per Ascian? Our 3 main boys where special, but the others were basically throw away tools... maybe they actvated more, especially considering the flow of time - i imagine doing any plans when there might be centuries between the shards within the time you find a new host...?

    I really wonder of the Arcadium or Preservation has some in em...
    (1)

Page 8 of 9 FirstFirst ... 6 7 8 9 LastLast