I am still following the discussion in this thread, but I finished the MSQ a week ago and didn't really have anything to say that hasn't already been said. I'll give it a go anyway.
MSQ
-_____________________-
A lot happened, and not a lot? I was hoping for Shepetto and Koana to meet, but everyone gets over hangups so quickly these days it's like any potential conflict was over before they actually met. It felt like a checklist item rather than a meaningful episode for, well, anyone actually.
The stuff with Gulool Ja's mother was just gross all around. Like, I'm glad she wasn't some impossibly pure doomed mother figure, but Ju-heee-zus. Big "extorting the sperm donor for childcare money" energy from that one. "Here, kid, turns out both your parents were just awful self-absorbed people and neither of them cared about you as a person at all." Oof.
And now we have Ascian(?!?)Sphene running around, but also Real(!?!)Sphene in play as well?(!?) It seems like the basic plan isn't actually to pick 5000 souls to save, but to seed a conflict among the Alexandrians to demonstrate to somebody (possibly us) that humans are all selfish bastards who are only in it for themselves and their immediate circle. Like, no duh?
It honestly wouldn't be a bad idea on paper, but aside from a few comically evil goons, everyone in this expansion has just been so perfectly perfect that the seed isn't really there in the current material, and it's only justified at all by DT's existence in continuity with ARR and Shadowbringers. I just can't see the current expac's citizenry escalating things to the extent that would make a compelling .3 patch. I'm sure everyone already knows the correct lesson to be learned here and just needs a single conveniently-timed speech to return to correct moral behavior. (To be fair to DT, XIV's writing already showed shades of this when Nanamo pulled an Aesop out of her hat in the conference with Varis back in Stormblood's patch cycle, but there it actually felt somewhat incisive.)
With memory manipulation in play, I found myself longing for a bigger, more ambitious twist to address the glaring tonal incongruity between Dawntrail and the earlier saga. What if our memories are wrong? Maybe DT felt so uncannily lighthearted and relatively low on consequence because we were made to forget all the bad stuff that actually happened? Maybe Valigarmanda razed a village or two before we brought it down? Maybe people died helping us during the contest who we don't even remember? Obviously there are all sorts of meta reasons that can't happen, but I wish I didn't spend most of the story wishing it understood how to effectively utilize the tools it gave itself.