The Formula won't change

[Voidmage]

I don’t agree with everything like that we have too much casual content (like not at all) or that fights should be easier to be solved mechanically but hit harder (there should be a balance. I like the thrice comes ruin mechanic but not everywhere. There comes a point where the health bar becomes useless).
This will also more or less give tanks just more tank privilege and casters a harder time because they are squishy.
I think we need harder hitting tank buster, more DoT on the players that can actually stack and more randomness on who the target of an attack is (an auto that every so often targets another player) as well as more tank responsibility.

With the rest I mostly agree.
Multiple path dungeons should be like in Variant dungeons. Not regarding treasure chests (every tank will probably just go the shortest route and I already see the drama of that) but with just different mobs, scenery and maybe boss mechanics.
Ideally it would be rng in what path you get.

The overworld needs more.
High level mobs running around (maybe higher than max level) even in the old zones (just make it so they don’t aggro new players), kinda like special enemies in Xenoblade with its own music and so on.
Make it so there are some that need groups and some that are like duels so everyone has something.

I like the lockpicking treasure chests idea. More chests in the overworld you can search for, they can have random rewards from tomestones to glamour,
Bonus points if you can find older savage gear in them.

All in all just more RNG and more use of things they learned in other content like field zones and implement those in the normal game.

If anything, I feel like there should be more challenging content for small groups of 4.
Like a savage version of 4-player dungeons you can do with your close friends instead of relying to statics that can have a less reliable longevity.

We have those already with criterion.
Even more savage is exactly not what this game needs.
We already have a good amount of challenging content for high end players in the form of savage, ultimate, chaotic in the future, Duels (yes some of them are really hard). Almost every mode has a savage version nowadays.
We need more things on moderate difficulty at most like CLL or Bozja critical engagements.

[Volgia]

Well if it has 3 more expansions left to live, it's 6 to 7 more years, I'd say that's fine by me.

[Arlythe]

We have those already with criterion.
Even more savage is exactly not what this game needs.
We already have a good amount of challenging content for high end players in the form of savage, ultimate, chaotic in the future, Duels (yes some of them are really hard). Almost every mode has a savage version nowadays.
We need more things on moderate difficulty at most like CLL or Bozja critical engagements.

We have a lot of savage content, true, but criterion dungeons are really not the answer for people who want to do various amount of hard content, but can't find a large enough static or who just want to play with a smaller group of friends or FC mates.
That's kinda like telling a viera player to be happy about all those nice hats in the game.
And now the devs put in more variety in even larger groups with the chaotic stuff, which is a step in the wrong direction tbh.
That doesn't have to mean we can't have more bozja-esque content.

We have more content than we've ever had. We didn't used to have 2 Ultimates, 3 Variant and 3 Criterion Dungeons, Field Operations, Deep Dungeons, Chaos Raids and misc content like Ishgard Restoration/Island Sanctuary/Cosmisc Exploration in ARR. Their older content like FATEs and hunts didn't used to be as rewarding but now have mount grinds. These things were added to the formula over time, including in recent expansions, but people want to pretend it doesn't exist and say the game is in maintenance mode.

That's what I usually like to say.
Just because there's not enough content that you deem playworthy, doesn't mean there's no content.

Well if it has 3 more expansions left to live, it's 6 to 7 more years, I'd say that's fine by me.

They already said they set up the story for the next 10 years and Yoshida seems confident enough that he can keep working on it until retiring.
Considering how long a lot of japanese people who work in artistic jobs keep on working past their retirement age, I'd say we'll be able to keep playing for quite some time.

[TomsYoungerBro]

We have a lot of savage content, true, but criterion dungeons are really not the answer for people who want to do various amount of hard content, but can't find a large enough static or who just want to play with a smaller group of friends or FC mates.

Its quite clear you didn't complete or even attempt the content. Criterion is exactly what you are looking for, but you disagree because...you can I guess?

[Arlythe]

Its quite clear you didn't complete or even attempt the content. Criterion is exactly what you are looking for, but you disagree because...you can I guess?

I mean if we just base this whole discussion on assumptions and accusations, sure.

[TomsYoungerBro]

I mean if we just base this whole discussion on assumptions and accusations, sure.

"I don't want criterion guys, I simply want criterion" xD

No assuming here. You didn't do the content. It's ok


The forums always deliever lmao

[Arlythe]

"I don't want criterion guys, I simply want criterion" xD

No assuming here. You didn't do the content. It's ok


The forums always deliever lmao

You could always just ask if you don't understand what I am saying instead of using such a passive aggressive undertone.
Do you want me to repeat it using simpler words so you understand or are you just here to troll, because then I'll pass, i have way more important things to do.

[TomsYoungerBro]

You could always just ask if you don't understand what I am saying instead of using such a passive aggressive undertone.
Do you want me to repeat it using simpler words so you understand or are you just here to troll, because then I'll pass, i have way more important things to do.

Nothing is really being missed here. You want criterion type content. It exists in the game (called criterion). You say you don't want it even though you explained it as a piece of content you would like. It exists in the game. You haven't done it before. You say it doesn't fit what you want, but you haven't done it. The only troll is you .

Edit:

Side note, you can already complete every piece of content out there with just the crafted gear that has been available and needs no tome farming nonsense. (well it does need some tomes but not near to what you need in order to be BiS)

This.

This is factually not true. The ultimate on-patch will require BiS gear while its current. This is how its always been from UCOB until now. You do the savage tier when its current to farm gear from the raid and tomes (with augments). You then use that gear in the next patch to attempt the ultimate on patch. Please do the content.