I'd love to see a similar breakdown of reviews from metacritic, although that makes it much harder to verify "real" players and hours played.

As sad as it is to see a game I love get bad reviews, it also deserves it. Dawntrail is just not good, and the longer time passes since its release, the clearer it becomes that this isn't just review bombing, a lot of people (like me) are very unsatisfied with this expansion and the state of the game. Every previous expansion to me has been between a 7/10 and 9/10. Never in my wildest dreams before Dawntrail released did I ever think I would give a FFXIV expansion a lower score than that. But here I am now with Dawntrail being a 4/10 for me. Even now, over three months later, I am still sometimes in shock by just how truly wretched the story, setting, and characters were.