No you cannot make everyone happy, and honestly trying too hard to make this the case is how we end up with people thinking that a relic grind for 1500 poetics is a good idea.

and honestly masking it behind "Well it isn't for you" is the opposite of making everyone happy, or trying to for that matter.

I understand that it can work for some issues, but a lot of issues always involves sacrificing some players for the sake of creating something that may be more well liked... This is sadly something I don't think they do well with at all.