The new dt beast tribes are out of touch with players desires.

[sindriiisgaming]

Honestly: dt as a whole is out of ouch.

I belive the new best tribes will be the pielu pielu, moglins and an unconfirmed race (pls God no hanu hanu) but of what we do know we know that these tribes offer nothing interesting in the story. And such was also the case for ew.

I personally loved that we got omicrons and learning about there race really added back something this game was missing since stb. But after such almost everything else was a boaring snore fest of skippable Cs. And now the accounced beast tribes for dt have once again got me waiting to hit that skip button over and over.


Who are these races for? Who is this story for? Who can seriously say they enjoyed the matanga btd? Who can seriously say the loprits had a good story and not just randomly creating a rave inside the moon. I hope se will find its roots again with the allied tribes and stop making stupid gag content like in endwalker and shb.

Perhaps this is only me, perhaps I'm the one wrong. But surely when you see the prospect of the peilu peilu and moglins you aren't exactly hyped either. And please don't try to make some case that all btd were bad. Fairies, omicron, moogles and even the arr sahagin had some really solid story's that got me interested. Hell sahagin even lore dump some cool stuff on u

[Shibi]

That little crafter town, near the Moblins - the run aways - will be the crafting beast tribe.

[CVXIV]

To each their own, I enjoy all of the beast tribes
Even ARR, despite how tedious they can be
I find the stories entertaining, and I like learning more about the characters

As for what we'll get in dawntrail though, I'm not sure

Combat could be the Yok Huy, and how they can come together with the ones who left and reach an understanding.

Gathering could be for the mamool ja which helps with their agriculture.

Crafting could be for the moblins and with the help of the former potsworn they end up rebuilding the bridge that was destroyed.

A lot of it would fit the themes of what we've seen in the expansion, coming together for the sake of peace and working hand in hand.

[Voidmage]

I wouldn’t say you are wrong neither you are right.

It’s just preferences in the tone of the beast tribes.

I agree though that DT seems to be too much in the more lighthearted direction.
I also agree that some tribes in EW were too much… normal for me.
The game says that the tribes are just normal people but why then have tribe quests instead of something else for a change.

In the beginning they fleshed out what was normally our enemy.
To this day I adore the Ixal quest line.
The Shb ones were also great because it gave a spin on the beast tribe stuff with the dwarfs / Lalafell.
Nowadays they are just normal side quests with normal people.

Anyway I think there is no right or wrong in this regard but I also wished there was a different approach this time.

[CVXIV]

I wouldn’t say you are wrong neither you are right.

It’s just preferences in the tone of the beast tribes.

I agree though that DT seems to be too much in the more lighthearted direction.
I also agree that some tribes in EW were too much… normal for me.
The game says that the tribes are just normal people but why then have tribe quests instead of something else for a change.

In the beginning they fleshed out what was normally our enemy.
To this day I adore the Ixal quest line.
The Shb ones were also great because it gave a spin on the beast tribe stuff with the dwarfs / Lalafell.
Nowadays they are just normal side quests with normal people.

Anyway I think there is no right or wrong in this regard but I also wished there was a different approach this time.

It's probably why they are trying to go more with the term allied society than beast tribes, since it has changed over the years. I did enjoy when it had to do with a faction of our enemy that wanted peace with everyone.

[CaptainLagbeard]

GoblinsMoblins are extremely likely DT's Crafting tribal quests

The Mamool Ja are probably going to end up being either gathering or combat, no idea what the last one would be.
Probably the giants in Urqopacha going to be one.

[Voidmage]

It's probably why they are trying to go more with the term allied society than beast tribes, since it has changed over the years. I did enjoy when it had to do with a faction of our enemy that wanted peace with everyone.

Probably yeah.
In my opinion they should try something new then though.
It’s fine to not see them as beast tribes anymore but they are more or less still treated like that by this game system then and in DT it makes the least sense.

Maybe a completely new approach would help nowadays. Sometimes it seems they just introduce new beast tribes just to keep this system going.

[Raikai]

I didn't mind them, although I think they could use more polish in their stories.

On a different note... I wish they would give them a little bit more love when creating their creature models. We basically get everyone wearing the same thing sans a color swap for that special one NPC, or a male/female variation in case of the Matanga. Makes sense for the Loporrits because that looks like an uniform, but not for the rest. I feel it would go a long way in making them a bit more fleshed out.

So far Mamool Ja's are the ones with the most model distinction, but even with them, gets a bit tiresome to see the same person in a different color.

[RaideDuku]

Apparently being outraged about current things have become so boring, we're being outraged about things that haven't happened yet, just so outrage levels can be maintained.

Sounds exhausting.

[Rein_eon_Osborne]

GoblinsMoblins are extremely likely DT's Crafting tribal quests

The Mamool Ja are probably going to end up being either gathering or combat, no idea what the last one would be.
Probably the giants in Urqopacha going to be one.

I think it’s the Giants too. There is a southern region in Urqopacha that looked like a village filled with hostile giants.