Frontlines over coordination Issues

[Mawlzy]

In your opinion, what is an appropriate level of coordination? Your example, to me, sounds like a normal level (we can even argue a minimal level) of coordination. You described a team working together to win a fight.

In my opinion, something is only over-coordination when it hurts your team's chances of winning.

Isn't the issue primarily one of whether the current job skills produce a required level of coordination for max win-rate that is healthy/enjoyable? If you take the approach that win-rate is everything, you form a premade with a meta stack and coordinate. Those who do just that mostly conclude this highly-coordinated approach is jolly good, whereas the rest of us mostly find it tedious.