BRD idea: Songs with MP usage

[Xieldras]

To me, it's one of those ideas that seems good on paper, and in terms class fantasy it kinda makes sense, but in practice it's not working. Part of me is inclined to think that putting all its power in its raid buffs has lead to it being plagued with so many problems with its rotation, and lack luster job design. It's why I'm obsessed with the PVP version of BRD because it feel like its personal firepower, and raid buff power are closer together in balance.

That's due to environment differences. In PvP a class is just allowed to be, while in PvE they have to be adjusted to encounter specifications and balanced because the Devs are terrified of a meta (especially one that has a rDPS in it), and also due to everyone having support surrounding the same 2min limitations. There are far more to design around in PvE. It didn't used to be like that before Dancer showed up and they gutted our own support kit. Bard was fine and working well before, so it cannot be a "good idea on paper but not in execution" scenario since it would imply that it wasn't working from its inception, which Stormblood disproves because of its popularity.
They have more than enough information from previous expansions about what worked with this class as well, so it's not like they're running short on ideas.

Back to OP, been thinking more about the MP usage. If we do tie the songs to MP, then the length would in general be around 15 seconds each no? That brings faster-paced gameplay, however 20 or 25 seconds would probably be best considering out current kit. Ballad was always the MP song, so it feels a bit weird for me personally to tie the MP regen to Paeon. Maybe a flip between both songs' effects? oGCD timer reset being on Paeon and the faster GCD + regen on Ballad. At least have all the songs available upon revive instead of locked behind cooldown.

[mallleable]

That's due to environment differences. In PvP a class is just allowed to be, while in PvE they have to be adjusted to encounter specifications and balanced because the Devs are terrified of a meta (especially one that has a rDPS in it), and also due to everyone having support surrounding the same 2min limitations. There are far more to design around in PvE. It didn't used to be like that before Dancer showed up and they gutted our own support kit. Bard was fine and working well before, so it cannot be a "good idea on paper but not in execution" scenario since it would imply that it wasn't working from its inception, which Stormblood disproves because of its popularity.
They have more than enough information from previous expansions about what worked with this class as well, so it's not like they're running short on ideas.

Back to OP, been thinking more about the MP usage. If we do tie the songs to MP, then the length would in general be around 15 seconds each no? That brings faster-paced gameplay, however 20 or 25 seconds would probably be best considering out current kit. Ballad was always the MP song, so it feels a bit weird for me personally to tie the MP regen to Paeon. Maybe a flip between both songs' effects? oGCD timer reset being on Paeon and the faster GCD + regen on Ballad. At least have all the songs available upon revive instead of locked behind cooldown.

My issue with tying songs to MP is that it would add another fail state to BRD's already massive pile of fail states for dying. Dying will leave you with no MP for songs. You could give BRD a button to recover MP, but then you are just adding hotbar bloat, and providing a fix to a problem that didn't need to be one in the first place. You could probably achieve a similar result by just making songs last like 25 seconds, make their recast be like 60 seconds, and give BRD two charges of each song. And then give BRD something to burn excess coda on like you get more gauge or a music themed attack as you will be getting twice as much coda with this system.