I never really enjoyed WoW very much. While I did hate DT's story, I'm enjoying the gameplay, so I'm sticking around. But if I was looking at a different MMO, it'd probably either be GW2 or ESO. I recall really enjoying ESO's stories and their pvp. It's been a long time, but I remember liking GW2's gameplay, especially their pvp. And while I'm sure I'd be the only player at this point, I did enjoy SWTOR for a great long while.