Warrior Rework to Balance the job

[Crafoutis]

Is the fun of WAR really from constant full self heals?

Yes, being able to full heal once every 30 seconds during trash packs only (it doesn't work this way in actual content, against bosses), is a majority of the flavor which makes me prefer WAR, and even subscribe to FFXIV at all.

I primarily play solo, while I do max out all classes and gear my roles via raiding, my primary method of interfacing with this game is soloing on WAR. It is why I choose WAR, it is my fun in the game. Whenever I'm playing SGE, I thank my lucky stars whenever I get a WAR as my tank, because I get to spend more time DPSing. So I personally don't get the whinging about 'mah role', because I spend a great deal of time healing and presently the only tank that makes me hate my job is DRK, the weakest one right now, the one that you can't take your eye off of for half a second otherwise it's curtains. That's not fun (for me).

I'd say that people taking issue with WAR ought to pick a more fun tank to heal for their static, but it's clear none of this conversation is about raiding at all, and is purely about Dungeons, which is the only place Bloodwhetting is so effective in group content.

[Masekase_Hurricane]

No thanks the job is working as intended

[Reimmi]

No thanks the job is working as intended

After they make bloodwhetting not heal per target, sure

[Tunda]

Warrior currently is omni role job. He do everything and still boring to play

[Launched]

Seems unnecessary, WAR is currently balanced and fun.

[WeakestZenosEnjoyer]

The damage kit of WAR is fine and I wouldn't want it to use hp as a damage resource and recover it back up, that absolutely should be DRK's space. (leveling ranges could be adjusted though, why is AoE beast gauge in ShB?)

The mitigation kit is dreadfully boring and "is the best at everything" is neither healthy for the game nor interesting to play, abilities like Bloodwhetting and Holmgang need to be reeled in and totally overhauled not Storm's Path/Eye.

[Tunda]

The damage kit of WAR is fine and I wouldn't want it to use hp as a damage resource and recover it back up, that absolutely should be DRK's space. (leveling ranges could be adjusted though, why is AoE beast gauge in ShB?)

The mitigation kit is dreadfully boring and "is the best at everything" is neither healthy for the game nor interesting to play, abilities like Bloodwhetting and Holmgang need to be reeled in and totally overhauled not Storm's Path/Eye.

I have a hot opinion.. Invulnerability skills are a clear sign for bad design jobs

[Ayan_Calvesse]

I have a hot opinion.. Invulnerability skills are a clear sign for bad design jobs

Agreed.

Invulns are "You don't wanna bother tanking this correctly" as a ability that for some reason has a diff timer for every class.; I cannot justify invulns because the idea that a capstone skill would vary so wildly. I could see a tank invuln as a tank LB if anything.

[AlessaImpera]

WARs already perfect, easily the best designed job. Just give me more screenshake and a few more buttons to press, and it would be even better.

[Gunz_Zbestest]

I have a hot opinion.. Invulnerability skills are a clear sign for bad design jobs

You call it bad job design. Square calls it extreme content. There will always be a boss with a tank buster meant to kill a tank. Do you mean that paladins should be the only class with hallowed ground?