one has to wonder if you skipped all the cutscenes, didnt read any narrative and instead read something on Reddit.

because you seem to be pulling much of this out of thin air. I liked Emet, thought he was decent, as a character, as a villain, would I call him "good"? no. when we met him in Elpis, sure.. he was good at that time. when we met him in the future... no, I wouldnt say he was a "good man" by any stretch. decent enough yes, good.... no.