Quote Originally Posted by Fiel_Tana View Post
Canonically, so are the sundered. Yet the story clearly shows that the sundered have a right to live.

Shadowbringers dealt with this exact theme and did it brilliantly, DT fails to even question it, that's the problem many people are having here and one of the reasons why DT is such a disappointment. According to Yoshi's quote, that was the intended theme of that area, to question what 'being alive' really means.
The sundered are all unique people distinct from the Ancients resulting from their effective death. SHB is pretty much nothing like what's going on here where we are dealing with exact perversions meant to function as the original identity.