I agree with the above poster. The Gibus should not be attached to a skullcap; that just looks stupid.

While I do refer to the LTW hat as "the dead rat", I think it's fine, and it definitely screams "Leatherworker".

I find the CRP hat to be rather... bland. I do like the quill pen on it though.

Overall, I think they did a good job. There are more hats that I like than those I don't.