Meleewalker to Meleetrail

[CrystalAurora]

Chiming in on the Viper/Ninja thing, although they can disconnect very easily compared to other melees, there's still Auto Attacks to consider. Swiftscale and Nin's haste decrease the auto attack timer by a significant margin. If a Viper just does triple Uncoiled Fury without being in melee range, they keep their GCD rolling, but they do lose uptime on autos. In that case, the Viper would lose around 400 or 500 potency from the missed autos. It seems small but worth trying to stick to the boss even if you are using UF.

That said, I agree with most other things in this thread. I had to quit RDM when I was doing Anabaseios in PF because I was so tired of underperforming melee doing, like, 2k more DPS than me while I was fighting my heart out. Judging by PCT, it might be the Resurrection keeping RDM and SMN down, but BLM isn't doing so hot right now either.

And Aiming players, rest in peace. They need to do something for that role stat or there will be a huge shortage in Arcadion.

Yes of course but when you are comparing said classes to other jobs in their role who have very low potency ranged attacks and who are also still missing some auto attacks from disengaging the gap between them would only increase the more that the boss forces disengage... not that I actually think that any sort of significant disengage will happen and I am not sure why people are expecting there to be enough to make the ranged tax meaningful.

As far as the Phys Ranged shortage I will say that it was already noticeable in Endwalker and considering they didn't do anything to draw people back into that role I expect it to be the same. Switching to melee last expansion was just funny to see that in a significant portion of the PFs healers would fill quicker than the physical ranged spot in savage.

[W00by]

My point with NIN and VPR was that because their auto attack CD is shorter, they miss more Autos than other jobs would. But they still handle downtime better, yeah.

I'm already feeling the ranged shortage, man. Recruiting for my Savage static, I can find a million and one melees but literally no aiming.

[Laerune]

I was planning maining BLM or PCT, then I saw how much we need the to move and went SMN, might go VPR.

[Ruminous]

Just recruit another caster, it's pretty much the same thing. Preferably a rdm if you need someone with a defensive. Magic barrier is pretty much the same thing unless the buster is a phys attack, which, you know, are pretty rare for raidbusters.

[Ramiee]

Phys range is in a bad spot
Bard is still a very awful job due to the tripling down on the song rotation and radiant finale.
Dancer basically became more brainless and overcaps on esprit like hell.
Machinist feels fine I guess but it's damage is awful.

Yeah bringing a picto to replace Phys range is a better choice tbh. Even RDM too since it has a raid buff and a raid shield. Phys range needs a complete role rework.

[Valence]

Let's not push it BRD is far from complex at a basic level. It's just finicky, not intuitive and annoying to optimize, but it's not exact rocket science either.

Phys range is in a bad spot
Bard is still a very awful job due to the tripling down on the song rotation and radiant finale.
Dancer basically became more brainless and overcaps on esprit like hell.
Machinist feels fine I guess but it's damage is awful.

Yeah bringing a picto to replace Phys range is a better choice tbh. Even RDM too since it has a raid buff and a raid shield. Phys range needs a complete role rework.

What's wrong with the song rotation? Besides that the recast could be adjusted? I think it's a neat and unique concept proper to the job. I'd kill to get something flavorful like that on mch...

[Supersnow845]

Let's not push it BRD is far from complex at a basic level. It's just finicky, not intuitive and annoying to optimize, but it's not exact rocket science either.



What's wrong with the song rotation? Besides that the recast could be adjusted? I think it's a neat and unique concept proper to the job. I'd kill to get something flavorful like that on mch...

I mean finicky not intuitive and annoying to optimise are exactly what makes it a difficult job

Think about it at baseline SAM is just keep banana up, do your midare loops spam shinten with kenki. Optimising it at baseline involves hagakure filler sticker dumps but it’s in the same position in the sense of it’s easy to just press everything as it lights up and do decent damage

BRD isn’t as hard to gold parse optimise as SAM but I’d certainly have it as harder than RPR, harder than NIN and around the DRG level

[GoatOfWar]

I mean finicky not intuitive and annoying to optimise are exactly what makes it a difficult job

Think about it at baseline SAM is just keep banana up, do your midare loops spam shinten with kenki. Optimising it at baseline involves hagakure filler sticker dumps but it’s in the same position in the sense of it’s easy to just press everything as it lights up and do decent damage

BRD isn’t as hard to gold parse optimise as SAM but I’d certainly have it as harder than RPR, harder than NIN and around the DRG level

Well, then you also have third eye and a lot of trial and error to see what you can get away with.
With some support, you can even take some tankbusters JUST for 10 extra Kenki. That's largely why parsing as Sam is difficult. Most of us don't go that extra mile.
The job itself isn't really complex- none of the jobs in this game are. I mean, i've seen groups let the Sam pull every fight JUST for 10 Kenki after the auto attack.

[Ramiee]

What's wrong with the song rotation? Besides that the recast could be adjusted? I think it's a neat and unique concept proper to the job. I'd kill to get something flavorful like that on mch...

If you die all of your songs are messed up and you lose all your damage and your reason for being there. Radiant finale buffs less, you do less damage and overall its incredibly punishing and so hard to recover from. It also means you have to stare at your song gauge often to see if your at the right time to switch songs so you can align with the 2 minute burst. If the game wasnt designed around raid buff alignment it would be more fine I would still hate it because this whole system reads Dancer far more to me then bard.

[Supersnow845]

BRD is in a really bad spot as it’s a legit complex job that gets terrible damage because of its role

If BRD was the same job but as a melee it would be up with RPR and VPR for the top spot, but since it’s a phys ranged it just gets randomly declared to do low damage despite its apparent complexity

Role shouldn’t dictate thereotical upper damage limits, job design should because right now BRD puts in so much effort to get so little out of it