Fem hroth rigging problems?

[Arohk]

I personally think female hrothgar are the perfect combo of slender and muscular. We are feminine enough, but are arms provide enough strength without looking weird. Which is why the armor scaling for some pieces are so crazy because it's treating our arms like male roe or male hrothgar when they really aren't that big at all.

Hoyoverse did it a lot better imo:

New Character Pulchra Fellini:



Slender looks just better than Bulky, but some people like the muscle ladies.

[Minali]

That's still barely more muscular than a catgirl, just with a bigger chest and a fox head.

[Absurdity]

Yes but we already have slender tiny catgirls, we don't need catgirls 2.0 with a different name slapped on them. I am very happy with their design, I'm just annoyed the gear doesn't fit. But these are two different topics.

Which is a problem that is unfortunately just not going to disappear.
All gear is designed for the female midlander body, as that is pretty much the "default" without any bone scaling applied. On top of that a lot of the gear has a relatively low polygon count for obvious reasons, it needs to run well with the assumption of a hundred players loaded at the same time.
What this means however is that things like sleeves and gloves are fit rather loosely to even the default body shape, so when applying the different racial scaling, especially more extreme bone scaling like female Roegadyn and female Hrothgar, it often ends up looking...goofy.

[Picothea]

Which is a problem that is unfortunately just not going to disappear.
All gear is designed for the female midlander body, as that is pretty much the "default" without any bone scaling applied. On top of that a lot of the gear has a relatively low polygon count for obvious reasons, it needs to run well with the assumption of a hundred players loaded at the same time.
What this means however is that things like sleeves and gloves are fit rather loosely to even the default body shape, so when applying the different racial scaling, especially more extreme bone scaling like female Roegadyn and female Hrothgar, it often ends up looking...goofy.

This comment looks as if you have not seen the difference between female hrothgar gear scaling and other bodies, including female roegadyn. The same items on hrothgar look significantly larger, and that's what really stands out to people.
I hope the gear worn on female hrothgar will eventually look similar in arm size to female roegadyn. That would be good enough for me.

[HeavenlyPeaches]

Helloo, I’d like to spark this convo/rigging problem up again… I found some pieces that are still REALLY REALLY big and bulky for no reason… I hoped they would fix more after 7.1 fixes… but I did not see any in 7.2x
I took these when I was a hrothgar and I would love to go back but the lack of hairstyles/hats and these really BIG BIG shoulders for no reason bothers me, Roe’s are also big but I feel like they have less issues with things like these…

Ty for reading! Lets spark this convo again and document all that we find again ������

[CidHeiral]

It seems they've been fixing a lot of these without saying anything in the patch notes. I was a female hrothgar for a few weeks recently and I only found two pieces that still had the issue (the skallic fending coat and the arm bands on their racial gloves) whereas previously it was almost everything in my glam chest.

I don't think anything is going to change with the shoulder plates. Personally I think it would look worse if they had smaller shoulder plates sitting there, like what they did to undead in WoW way back in the day.