Gil is worthless.

[Nebelheim]

"I have a lot of gil and nothing to spend it on so it feels worthless. I want it to be worth something."
"Give it to me for free then."
"No, I want it to be worth something."

No logical inconsistency. You're just reading OP in bad faith for Twitter Dunk Points.

Not really people are pointing out how op is saying how gil is worthless then back peddling saying it's worth something after people pointed out how their ideas will cause hyperinflation. And the people asking for gil are only saying that considering they made claims gil was worthless and if it was worthless then why not hand out gil only for them to say it's worth too much in value irl and in game. I don't think anyone was serious about asking for gil either and only making a point that the op made of it being "so worthless".