Astrologian changes feedback

[Sylvain]

The key point is that, the dev team should provide a greater variety of jobs for players to choose from, rather than "deciding for the players" and assuming they just like simple jobs.

But you can swap it around.
You, as a good player, have the opportunity to choose your job because you can play any job.
So the choice between WHM/AST or SCH/SGE or BLM/SMN is up to your liking because you'll excel at all these jobs.

A bad player doesn't have that choice because well... they're bad.

So WE are left with WHM and WHM with stars, but atm some players are left with WHM because WHM with stars are too complicated. (Not that I believe the change will change much)

I think that, rather than the current Caster situation of 'BLM for big brain, SMN for easystreet, RDM for prog' or whatever, each job should have its own individual sliding scale of complexity.

They should, they "kinda" do, it's just that the sliding scale for SMN and BLM are just light years appart. I don't find AST healing to be that complex, but the card system does put off many people. So again, we can choose, they can't. If "they" is 5 times as many as "we" then technically speaking it's better for the game to have more people able to enjoy more jobs.

By making the potency 'gained' from engaging with the extra complexity be a smaller amount, it makes it feel less 'required'.

Yes, I agree 100%.
It is kind of the case with SCH and the AF or AST with proper cards management vs just "throwing any card whenever it's up".

Indeed they could go for more. But clearly they don't want because apparently it would make healer scarier to play. Personally I've never heard anyone say "I'm afraid to play a healer because I don't think i'll be able to keep up with the rotation".