Character graphical changes are NOT in an acceptable state, please make it optional

[Luluna]

I also noticed when I put my characters in Gridania in the guild they looked just more or less the same only better colours and more polished. It does seem to be a lot of lighting changes thing idk.

I made a cat girl and she was lovely her hair and eyes looked really nice in the benchmark. I am unsure on some of my Hyur features but with no benchmark for PS5 I will have to wait and I will be spending the beginning of the expac remaking my character

[potatsdevourer]

Tried scrutinizing my female Highlander on benchmark. Pretty sure eyes are not supposed to have that bump, right?

[Loggos]

I've already posted this in another thread but I do think this is a point worth making. I'm sorry for repeating it:

I really wish they'd gone the reverse ARR route. When they changed the graphics from 1.0 to ARR the quality dropped of course but the identity of the characters stayed largely intact.

I had hoped the graphical update would have meant increasing the quality while keeping the core facial features/identity.

Realistically, I am aware they probably can't just straight-up go back to 1.0 character graphics. This may very well not be possible from a technical standpoint.
And in many other aspects the current benchmark is probably much better, esp. when it comes to the portrayal of nature/the environment and the modelling of certain physical properties such as light, translucence, depth etc. etc.

But I think the example shows how amping up the fidelity without losing character identity and uniqueness could look like.

https://youtu.be/p64H66IurrY?t=72

I know the video quality is rather bad but I'm under the impression that this miqo'te face looks pretty much identical to its corresponding ARR+ counterpart (or at least preserves its key personality).
Its quality is just considerably better.

Also, a little bonus:
https://youtu.be/ksuoipNWKWs?t=338
https://youtu.be/oD45euKWO1U?t=151
https://youtu.be/oD45euKWO1U?t=182

Again, I know, a direct comparison with 1.0 is not completely fair and I don't actually demand we go back, as much as I praise (some! of) its character graphics. But if this character presentation was possible in 2011, then I would have hoped we could have at least gotten something similar/that comes close in 2024.

[cutestfox]

I've already posted this in another thread but I do think this is a point worth making. I'm sorry for repeating it:

Again, I know, a direct comparison with 1.0 is not completely fair and I don't actually demand we go back, as much as I praise (some! of) its character graphics. But if this character presentation was possible in 2011, then I would have hoped we could have at least gotten something similar/that comes close in 2024.

That's all I could've ever really wanted
some higher quality textures, improved lighting
there was absolutely no need to make these random changes to the faces

[xbahax92]

That's all I could've ever really wanted
some higher quality textures, improved lighting
there was absolutely no need to make these random changes to the faces

Overdramatizing won't help, though. Some of the issues are clearly bugs and let's not forget some other issues are man-made, which need to be corrected.

I'll rather use this chance and tell them how bad their character creator is. It's probably one of the most outdated CC. Some of the facial features are limited. There are clearly not enough beard, fang, tail, scale, etc. options.
The color palette is very limited and untouched. There is no proper lighting option and this should be adressed first. It's really annoying when you cannot design your character with proper "sunlight".

[kingskye]

this is still under development, lol

[Ceetee]

this is still under development, lol

Of course it is? Thats why we are all giving feedback. It wouldn't be helpful to do so after they FINISHED development and weren't going to touch it anymore.

[Loggos]

Those bunny glow stick ears are absolutely sending me oh my god. ;____;

[coffeepotz]

People sure are worked up.

Big Gulps huh? Alrighht.

Welp, see ya later

[SongOfTheWind]

Lip colour for some races seems broken more than others. For light skinned (both rava and veena) mviera dark/light/none barely makes a difference now. For darker skin tones it starts to work suddenly (rava only)
But this felezen is a pretty drastic example of no colour resulting in dark brown/wine all of a sudden. So the problem seems to be more than just matte finish.