Results 1 to 10 of 159

Hybrid View

  1. #1
    Player
    Risough's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2023
    Posts
    29
    Character
    Acheno Oronir
    World
    Diabolos
    Main Class
    Dragoon Lv 64
    Thank you for providing some additional context, Malthir. I've seen both of the sources you mentioned and I actually linked the highlander lore thread earlier in this one. I'll provide the text of the blurb from the character creator for convenience here:

    Character Creator:
    Quote Originally Posted by Character Creator
    The Highlanders were the first of the Hyur to reach Eorzea. Their name derives from their long tradition of building strongholds in the mountains. Compared to their Midland brethren, the Highlanders are noticeably larger in build.

    Of late, Highlanders have become an increasingly rare sight in Eorzea, their number represented almost exclusively by those who fled Ala Mhigo after its fall and now work in the desert city-state of Ul'dah as mercenaries and sellswords.
    I quoted the excerpt on eyebrows from the highlander lore thread in this post.

    The blurbs in the character creator hold information to help you come up with your own background for your character and understand how others might see them in the world, but nothing in that last sentence is forced on your character. I interpret that "almost" qualifier is added to the blurb for that reason.

    I also dug up the quote from Deep Canyon that Luluya mentioned:
    Quote Originally Posted by Deep Canyon
    I must say, you're not what I was expectin'. I was sure Adalberta's newest protégé would be an Ala Mhigan—like every other miner this place produces these days. But I'll wager you're from even farther afield... an' that you're an adventurer. Hmph.
    You'll get this same text even if you play as a Highlander, so Highlander WoLs are not canonically Ala Mhigan.
    (3)

  2. #2
    Player
    Malthir's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2018
    Posts
    362
    Character
    Malthir Durnith
    World
    Cerberus
    Main Class
    Dark Knight Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Risough View Post
    Thank you for providing some additional context, Malthir. I've seen both of the sources you mentioned and I actually linked the highlander lore thread earlier in this one. I'll provide the text of the blurb from the character creator for convenience here:

    Character Creator:


    I quoted the excerpt on eyebrows from the highlander lore thread in this post.

    The blurbs in the character creator hold information to help you come up with your own background for your character and understand how others might see them in the world, but nothing in that last sentence is forced on your character. I interpret that "almost" qualifier is added to the blurb for that reason.

    I also dug up the quote from Deep Canyon that Luluya mentioned:


    You'll get this same text even if you play as a Highlander, so Highlander WoLs are not canonically Ala Mhigan.
    Which is true, I was saying that you are canonically Ala Mhigan when it comes to cultures, clearly I didn't word my initial statement well. The culture of eyebrow shaving and tooth filing, scarification etc pre dates even that. So while it is true you could say your WoL is a rare exception to being Ala Mhigan, you are still from the same culture of Highlanders. The conversation I was replying to in my first comment, was to someone claiming your highlander could have come from a culture different culture of highlanders that didn't do this. However as stated in the lore, the Eorzean highlanders as a clan survived the 4th Umbral calamity by taking refuge in the mountains around Gyr Abania, it then goes on to talk about the culture of eyebrow shaving, tooth filing, tooth removal, scaring. The highlanders operated functionally as nomadic mercs for years, until later unifying as one people and creating the Country of Ala Mhigo.

    So to reiterate, while you have a very rare chance of seeing a Eorzean Highlander that's not from Ala Mhigo, which means your WoL could have been born somewhere else, ALL highlanders come from a culture of shaving eyebrows and scaring etc. Not disagreeing that it should be an optional facial feature the same way the scars are, I was disagreeing with the notion that's there's different Highlander cultures across Eorzea, there isn't.
    (0)
    Last edited by Malthir; 06-03-2024 at 02:00 AM.