First of all, I think it's important to note that the character creator has never been a perfect indicator of what your character will look like in-game. That said, I don't hate it (honestly the new version looks closer to how I like to draw him). My main critiques are: (1) I don't like how flat his lips look when he's not in direct light, (2) I don't like how dark the shadows under his eye and on his nose looks when he's not in direct light, and (3)I don't like how bright the highlight on his nose looks in direct light (the highlight creates this waxy/plastic effect I don't like). Otherwise, I like the shape of his hair, lips, and jaw- they are a definite upgrade. His hair color is more desaturated, but this doesn't bother me that much.