Thoughts On: "Thalik's Favor" for All Gathering Jobs.

[Covenant]

While it fits and an argument could be said that both miner and botanist have another skill that boost collectability. I think grants "Extra Boosts" from gather to be used for GP could be nice.

The question is what's the equivalents of "hooking a big fish" in miner and botanist classes...without the return of HQ items". Maybe, reintroducing "hidden items" at all or highest levels (single items like seeds) could grant the bonus.

Alternatively, a return of "streaks" (which were consecutive "HQ" strikes)?

Or, Like Byegrots Blessing, perhaps instead of a quality burst, we can burn for a progress burst?

[Hasrat]

Thing is, BTN/MIN always know exactly what they're spending GP on, so it's entirely on the player to decide how to manage GP use.

FSH is largely reliant entirely on RNG. You might not get what you want, it might take longer than expected, you might straight up spend GP and get absolutely nothing out of it, etc.

FSH having GP recovery makes sense as a mitigation for any losses due to bad luck. BTN/MIN don't have nearly as many luck elements involved to work around, so their GP use is more consistent.

[Calysto]

You could have the "gatherer's art" earning capped at 15% chances (so RNG and a memento of old HQ)

It also could be a way to add RNG in those jobs : beside "Nophica's Favor" (for flavor), you could spend "Arts" on "chances to" like "gather more", "not use node", "reduce next action cost", etc...