Moogle Treasure Trove: Weekly & Minimog: Please assign by MSQ progress!

[Minali]

The Mogpendium of my alt who is currently in 2.4:
https://imgur.com/a/PwKHIT8

60 Tomestones I could just grab on my endgame main character who doesn't have a big need for them anymore because I already collected a lot of rewards the usual non-mogtome way.
Moogle Treasure Trove always had this purpose of making people unlock side content they haven't done before, I support this general idea and respect it. However, I highly doubt anyone would expect a 2.4 character to rush to the Shadowbringers patches and unlock Eden - maybe even play until 5.3 if it's the last Eden tier. These ??? are three weeks in which a character like my alt could have been motivated to unlock optional ARR dungeons like Sastasha (hard). How likely is someone to do this if they can just run Cutter's Cry or a MSQ dungeon they already have? This kind of randomization ignoring MSQ progress works against the very thing this event feature is trying to accomplish. Meanwhile the characters who need tomes and tome rewards the most are the ones having to put in much more work when they can't do these challenges. There is really no good reason to keep this way of assigning duties to these challenges the way it is now. Please, dear devs, if you want us to unlock duties we might not have touched yet, make sure it's a duty that's within reach.

[CaptainLagbeard]

Hopefully they figure out how to make the weekly challenges always be something actually doable by the character by the time the second hunt rolls around.

[Thurmnmurmn]

It would need to be by unlocks and not by msq. Eden per example isn't part of the msq.
But yeah they really should figure out a way to do it sooner than later.

[CaptainLagbeard]

It would need to be by unlocks and not by msq. Eden per example isn't part of the msq.
But yeah they really should figure out a way to do it sooner than later.

Well you can do Eden 1-8 immediately after you beat Hades and finish the quest Shadowbringers, and 9-12 should be available after Seat of Sacrifice and relevant MSQ... With MSQ progression, it'd be more based on what you CAN unlock.

[Minali]

Well you can do Eden 1-8 immediately after you beat Hades and finish the quest Shadowbringers, and 9-12 should be available after Seat of Sacrifice and relevant MSQ... With MSQ progression, it'd be more based on what you CAN unlock.

Indeed. It's ok (and maybe even the point) to give people an extra reason to unlock side content. This side content should just be within reasonable reach and that's what tying it to MSQ progress would be good for.

[Thurmnmurmn]

Well you can do Eden 1-8 immediately after you beat Hades and finish the quest Shadowbringers, and 9-12 should be available after Seat of Sacrifice and relevant MSQ... With MSQ progression, it'd be more based on what you CAN unlock.

True but I'm thinking more of making it an equal outcome for everyone.
Everyone should have whatever challenge they get be accessible already.

[CaptainLagbeard]

True but I'm thinking more of making it an equal outcome for everyone.
Everyone should have whatever challenge they get be accessible already.

If it is something that the player can unlock and go do, it is reasonable for being on the weekly mogstone challenge. The problem it currently has is that it can give someone still doing ARR something from all the way in ShB, which they can't even unlock if they wanted to.

[Mel0hDee]

Four weeks of not being able to do the weekly on my Alt.

[NobleJanobii]

Just coming in to add that this is still a problem in the second round. I have two alts who are in Heavensward. One alt has not been able to do any of the weekly mog challenges thus far because all three of his weekly challenges have been the Ivalice raids: see here. The other alt has only been able to do one so far, but was unable to do the first week or this week because their weekly challenges were Ivalice and the Four Lords: see here and here. And here's another alt who is in Post-ARR who hasn't been able to do any weeklies because once again, all tied to Four Lord and Ivalice content, see here: https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachmen...fbc42f0c66195&

These alts are nowhere close to being able to unlock any of these raids MSQ progress wise, as they would require me to complete Heavensward and Stormblood to unlock. And while you could say 'just grind the tomes on your main and trade whatever item it is to your alt', several items on the list such as the Ala Mhigan barding are not tradeable, so that's not a viable solution. Thus, I am all for tweaking the system to limit the weekly mog challenge based on MSQ progression! It would make the system a lot more newbie and alt friendly overall. Thank you!

[CamuiKushi]

Honestly I haven't been able to do almost all my weeklies on my alt. The organisation of the whole event feels very confused. On my main I have absolutely zero need for any of the rewards available and on my alt I can't even do the most rewarding tasks.
While I'm complaining, Wonderous Tails is also still giving tasks that haven't been unlocked even though I thought they changed this???