It has always been difficult to do well as MNK in PvP, and yet over time this job becomes steadily weaker. Shortening Earth Resonance isn't a minor adjustment. Now it has less time to compile both damage and healing, so not only can't it heal as much anymore, it's also further away from doing significant damage. And this is in addition to how clumsy the ability is, because it has to be manually activated to do Early's Reply. Not only that, it has a very significant delay from when it is activated to when the ability actually does something. How wonderful it would be, if the MNK can choose to either manually activate Earth's Reply, or having it activate on its own when the duration expires.