Scrolling through a lot of posts about the Borderless Window setting to find answers to my problem and nothing. It did help me realize what the real problem has been all along: The game is thinking that both my monitors are 1600 x 900. It's something I noticed but never seemed to have it click that that's what my resolution in-game has been.

It shouldn't be defaulting to that. Every setting I've checked for my monitor and graphics card have confirmed that I'm suppose to be hitting 1920x1080. Does anyone else have experience with this and know if there is something I'm missing?