What is interesting to me, in that Reddit thread, especially since it's FFXIVDiscussion (not the mainsub itself), is how many people are happy with SGE. FFXIVDiscussion, when talking healers, tends to be a "-lite" version of here with most of the people agreeing with you and the others here, just more subdued and a bit more...balanced?...not sure the right word for it, but you get the idea; a toned down version of here.

But in that thread...the vast majority of posts seem to be really happy with SGE. Some wish it was a little more DPS focused, but are praising it at the same time, and many are outright praising it with no caveats. RPR, oddly enough, seems to be getting the (slightly) more mixed reception, but FFXIVDiscussion seems to actually like SGE a lot. I was not expecting that.