Very minor sage idea

[ty_taurus]

The concept of “healing by attacking” needs to incorporate ways to approach healing that require you think about different attack spells to use when healing is required. The problem with Kardia currently is that every DPS spell has a Kardia effect and all Kardia effects are the same. Whether Kardia exists or not makes no difference because you’d be casting the same spells in the same order anyway. Your choices don’t matter.

If you change Kardia’s effects from restoring HP to generating gauge, we get the same dilemma.

[Sani2341]

The concept of “healing by attacking” needs to incorporate ways to approach healing that require you think about different attack spells to use when healing is required. The problem with Kardia currently is that every DPS spell has a Kardia effect and all Kardia effects are the same. Whether Kardia exists or not makes no difference because you’d be casting the same spells in the same order anyway. Your choices don’t matter.

If you change Kardia’s effects from restoring HP to generating gauge, we get the same dilemma.

Man. Imagine if like dosis just did the current kardia effect, E. Dosis had kardia do a Regen and dyskrasia split it between heal + tiny shield.

All tuned to provide effectivly the same dmg undone/prevented but in different ways thus at least having the Potential to be prefered in different situations other than their dmg potency.

Probably could also give phlegma an aoe heal kardia centered on the kardia target.

[Allegor]

The concept of “healing by attacking” needs to incorporate ways to approach healing that require you think about different attack spells to use when healing is required. The problem with Kardia currently is that every DPS spell has a Kardia effect and all Kardia effects are the same. Whether Kardia exists or not makes no difference because you’d be casting the same spells in the same order anyway. Your choices don’t matter.

If you change Kardia’s effects from restoring HP to generating gauge, we get the same dilemma.

That's kinda why I wish Kardia was more involved in SGE's identity and gameplay, not just a Regen with extra steps. Heck, you could remove Kardia as a mechanic and add an actual Regen and nothing about the job would change.

Sure it would. Regens work continuously and Kardia only works when there are living enemies in range to attack. If your entire worldview is centered around doing boss raid gameplay, I can understand why you wouldn’t see the difference, but that is a significant difference. Kardia cannot ever be used to heal up between fights.

So you're basically saying it'd be improved if Kardia was replaced with a Regen, which is even worse for the job identity lol