So I feel the main thing thats been said so far is job engagement and content engagement need to go hand in hand, if we take DRG and BRD in stormblood for example. During Omega you wanted to have a Ranged DPS usually BRD and DRG paired for their buffs and how they played off each other, around this time we saw some rather simple fights in Omega, such as Chadernook, a very tank and spank fight, infact, we also had Phantom Train that tier as well. These fights, normal and savage were VERY simple in design and what was required to clear, given the simplicity we had a lot of room for many unique interactions and synergy between jobs, such as how NIN would help deal with healer aggro, and provide slashing debuffs.

Now I ofc want to say these are very very small tiny details people usually looked over, but now, we don't even have that Tanks and healers are the only two roles to interact with the party and each other directly. If a fight is going to be a tank and spank, the jobs should have enough complexity to make up for what will be a simple fight that focuses simply on the damage needed to kill it, as well as the self same jobs providing a rewarding experience for mastering their kits and being able to adjust when a fight requires more mechanic focued management and resolution.

This is ofc primarily talking about how jobs are affecting one another as well as their reaction to content type or situations there within. An example of job interaction with their own kits is tanks losing emnity, and how we had two rotations built in, aggro and dps,how we had to maintain stances and adjust them accordingly, and how one with enough skill could forgo the use of an aggro rotation and focus strictly on their dps. We have no content to compensate for the removel of these types of interactions, we have no interactions between roles and jobs to rely on bar the basic tank and healer interactions that are standard if you want to clear, and the most tanks can do now is give the party single target mit which, if things are going right, doesn't happen.

We cannot talk about job individually truly, as the entire system for both jobs and content are currently overly simplified, and the jobs and content must play into the system, the system neeeds to be changed for any nuanced discussions to occur. In my opinion.