This game needs to be harder

[sindriiisgaming]

Alright, just hear me out ok. this is not another OMG every1 in 14 suxxxx thread.
i genuinly think there is a currently huge problem with the games entry level expectations of players at 90 content.

we got some healer today, in grand cosmos. level 80 dng.. with no holy, freecure I farming, and not using a single lilly. and this is the issue imo. this game does abolutley nothing to check players are at the suitable level to enter these dungeons,
players now are able to buy boosts on the first ever character before ever completing any job properly first, players are able to buy msq skips and rush the game without learning anything, and fundimentally. this is making for a worse experience for the general players.

how you ask? well because when my tank comes into expert, or 80dng.. and he doesnt know what TBN is, he doesnt want to use rampart and instead spams clemency on himself, or my healer is refusing to use kardia on the tank, or my fellow dps are spamming 1-1-1-1 in there rotations, not wearing even a JOBSTONE i think something is wrong.

this game needs more checks on the players, because it HAS undenieably been making dungeon and raid content harder for casuals.. my god just look at 1st boss in dead ends. yet its doing nothing to make sure theyre up to the skill level of that boss.

check for crystals, check for first account boosting, check they didnt skip there job quests... something anything.. but rn this is such a huge issue every1 is suffering from in some way or another... i feel even as i type this.. people will read this and think im a troll, ask what the point of this post was, or attack me in some fasion not understand whats really wrong.. but i just hope somebody out there understands what im talking about... and how frustrating this really is becomming....

just stop rushing people into endgame.. its a genuine disservice to your great early game. stop setting new jobs at 70/80 and set them at ONE... its overwhelming! don't let people buy any skips before they hit max level on there main on those jobs AND MSQ first... dont let people into dng without crystals on.. i think this would be a good QOL for everyone, even those poor players who get humiliated in dngs because they didnt realize why skipping was so bad

[KitingGenbu]

I do wish jobs started lower or at least had certain perquisites other than just being the level. Example, having a tank at 60 to be able to unlock GNB or a healer at 70 to be able to unlock SGE. Going from 70 DRG to 70 SGE isn't exactly an easy task for just anyone and makes others suffer as well.

It does make me think of the days when people had to level the job up to unlock the ability. So many new DRK tanks without Provoke, fun times. Or even when cleric stance was a thing and seeing healers trying to heal with it on and wondering why people were dying (because it would lower your healing output by like 50% or something like that). Aside from caster BRD/MCH, HW was a pretty fun time to play (for the lulz at least).

[sindriiisgaming]

I do wish jobs started lower or at least had certain perquisites other than just being the level. Example, having a tank at 60 to be able to unlock GNB or a healer at 70 to be able to unlock SGE. Going from 70 DRG to 70 SGE isn't exactly an easy task for just anyone and makes others suffer as well.

It does make me think of the days when people had to level the job up to unlock the ability. So many new DRK tanks without Provoke, fun times.

i wish jobs all started at level 1. i feel genuinly sad i couldn't take my rpr/sage from 1-90. it was so hard to learn because of it

[Atelier-Bagur]

I would personally want for bosses to attack more frequently and deal more party/raid wide damage for healers to do more healing than dps'ing and for bosses to have more visual telegraphs for attacks rather than the danger circles we have.

A healthy mix of these would probably help keep the fights from being snoozefests.

Also btw, we shouldnt try to cater to people who pay to skip and try to do content asap. Thats a personal fault on them and not the game where previous dungeons and fights introduce to you common mechanics earlier. I will agree that perhaps having a rotation tutorial of some sort can help with teaching players more on how a class plays.

[sindriiisgaming]

I would personally want for bosses to attack more frequently and deal more party/raid wide damage for healers to do more healing than dps'ing and for bosses to have more visual telegraphs for attacks rather than the danger circles we have.

A healthy mix of these would probably help keep the fights from being snoozefests.

Also btw, we shouldnt try to cater to people who pay to skip and try to do content asap. Thats a personal fault on them and not the game where previous dungeons and fights introduce to you common mechanics earlier. I will agree that perhaps having a rotation tutorial of some sort can help with teaching players more on how a class plays.

we can never have rotation tutorials in this game because that would mean devs deciding on the "correct rotation" the job i play (rpr) has 2 openers both of which are viable (early enshroud, early gluttony) and both lead to good results. if the devs did rotation toturlas theyde effectly be forcing meta rotations onto everyone, and you need a new one like every 4 levels for certian jobs, like mch.

[strawberrycake]

It's much clearer to send feedback to the devs and ask for "rewarding more decision making instead of just execution" in battle content, than to say "jobs have been dumbed down".

The latter can be misunderstood, and I'm prepared for the downvotes by saying this. The person reading a feedback that says "jobs have been dumbed down and are all the same" can easily misunderstand that the players want there to be more rewards and more challenges on execution. The natural outcome is that, it takes a while longer for rotations to be solved, but at the moment they are solved, the challenge is gone and the job feels "all the same" again.

This is the issue with the current state of XIV

[Atelier-Bagur]

we can never have rotation tutorials in this game because that would mean devs deciding on the "correct rotation" the job i play (rpr) has 2 openers both of which are viable (early enshroud, early gluttony) and both lead to good results. if the devs did rotation toturlas theyde effectly be forcing meta rotations onto everyone, and you need a new one like every 4 levels for certian jobs, like mch.

I actually was thinking that too since I believe optimal play is more of a community thing than a developer thing (despite the fact that they're the ones whom developed the jobs) so having official rotations would just be both ignored or enforced, which leads to more people quitting. Even if the jobs are still easy to play anyway; they'll be held back by the newly enforced optimal meta by the community.

[OgruMogru]

It's a player psychology thing though and I cannot see any simple solution to changing the way people think about and approach the game without being harsh or gatekeepy. It makes me feel so hostile it's horrible! Like, its not a moral failure to be bad at something, but it is to refuse to improve or interface with a something that is reliant on group participation.

[DiaDeem]

I think MSQ is fine being as is... but stuff like Alliance Raids and Normal Raids I feel would benefit from a higher difficulty. Something similar to CLL/DR/Dal I think would be fun.

I'll also keep yelling until someone hears me about them bringing back HM Dungeons.

[Turtledeluxe]

Everything Yoshi P touches lately assumes you're an idiot unfortunately. That seems to be his recipe for attracting a wider audience...you know in the years Elden Ring and BG3 are dominating video game discourse.