Redo FFXIV: Remove the dance, introduce RNG encounters

[Jojoya]

The casuals right now sweating imagining your idea and having to actually not be afk all the time in roulettes :

Randomizing mechanics wouldn't change anything if they're already AFKing through the fights. They could still AFK because ignoring mechanics has been proven non-fatal.

I'm fine with randomizing as long as mechanics were already introduced to the player through bosses that were previously defeated either in MSQ or earlier parts of the same duty. If new mechanics get introduced, then have the mechanics appear in a specific order at the start of the encounter than randomize them after that. Ultimately there is still going to be a dance involved but it's just the order of the steps changing instead of the steps being completely different.

I don't know why people on these forum are so against the idea of fun. Doing the exact same fight is just boring. Having said that, fights have some degree of randomness already (albeit very little), yet nobody cares. It's just a fun thing if you raid and you get "(un)lucky" and everyone laughs about it.

What is fun to you may not be fun to another player.

As for getting an unlucky combination, like you said it's something to laugh about and try again. Unfortunately, too many players present any type of failure as meaning a player is bad and so players hate getting placed into situations where there's a strong chance of failure. It's rather ironic considering that the players who fail the most are the highly skilled players tackling the most difficult content. They don't let failure hold them back. Those who leave a party after a single wipe do.