Page 7 of 23 FirstFirst ... 5 6 7 8 9 17 ... LastLast
Results 61 to 70 of 280

Hybrid View

  1. 05-31-2023 07:57 PM

  2. #2
    Player
    Ayche's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2021
    Posts
    328
    Character
    Aychelle Tripler
    World
    Raiden
    Main Class
    Paladin Lv 100
    In all honesty, any answer to why big people turned into catgirls and elves is probably going to sound asinine. I mean they get asked the question and feel responsible to respond with something, but it is almost worse trying to really rationalize it. You will just dig yourself into a hole if you need to explain catgirls and lalafell.
    (6)

  3. #3
    Player
    Cleretic's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2021
    Location
    Solution Eight (it's not as good)
    Posts
    3,279
    Character
    Ein Dose
    World
    Mateus
    Main Class
    Alchemist Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Ayche View Post
    In all honesty, any answer to why big people turned into catgirls and elves is probably going to sound asinine. I mean they get asked the question and feel responsible to respond with something, but it is almost worse trying to really rationalize it. You will just dig yourself into a hole if you need to explain catgirls and lalafell.
    I dunno, I understood it well enough the moment I realized that meant the sahagin were probably the fragments/descendants of the guys who were Really Into Sharks.
    (6)

  4. #4
    Player
    Lurina's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2019
    Posts
    334
    Character
    Floria Aerinus
    World
    Balmung
    Main Class
    White Mage Lv 80
    Quote Originally Posted by Ayche View Post
    In all honesty, any answer to why big people turned into catgirls and elves is probably going to sound asinine. I mean they get asked the question and feel responsible to respond with something, but it is almost worse trying to really rationalize it. You will just dig yourself into a hole if you need to explain catgirls and lalafell.
    I agree, but they said it, so we have no choice but to try and have it make sense. Or else we might wonder why we're on a forum devoted to obsessing over JRPG story minutia at all and have to question our life choices.

    Quote Originally Posted by Cleretic View Post
    I dunno, I understood it well enough the moment I realized that meant the sahagin were probably the fragments/descendants of the guys who were Really Into Sharks.
    I just posted the quote that rebuts that interpretation of how it works! You can't just say it anyway!

    ...I mean, you can, because none of this is even really important to the rest of the lore anyway and is basically meaningless fluff, but...
    (8)
    Last edited by Lurina; 06-01-2023 at 03:10 AM.

  5. #5
    Player
    Iscah's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2017
    Posts
    14,308
    Character
    Aurelie Moonsong
    World
    Bismarck
    Main Class
    Red Mage Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Brinne View Post
    I'm not sure why the suggestion of "Emet-Selch's biased viewpoint" must necessarily reflect "oh, he must be lying in the third-person sequence written by Ishikawa about his experiences and perspective for no reason" instead of "he simplifies and partially sanitizes the explanation of what was a horrifying and traumatic experience for him when speaking to a crowd that includes a child."
    Ryne is not a child, she is described as a young woman – and Emet is trying to horrify them and convey the horror he felt. If he was trying to protect her poor childish sensibilities then surely he wouldn't have picked her to creep out with a duplicate?

    Either we accuse him of being inaccurate in one of those two passages or we accuse him of it in the other. All points considered, I think inaccuracy in the non-FFXIV story to be more likely.
    (8)

  6. #6
    Player
    Kozh's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2020
    Posts
    1,075
    Character
    Corvo Aerden
    World
    Kujata
    Main Class
    Dark Knight Lv 98
    Quote Originally Posted by Iscah View Post
    Ryne is not a child, she is described as a young woman – and Emet is trying to horrify them and convey the horror he felt. If he was trying to protect her poor childish sensibilities then surely he wouldn't have picked her to creep out with a duplicate?

    Either we accuse him of being inaccurate in one of those two passages or we accuse him of it in the other. All points considered, I think inaccuracy in the non-FFXIV story to be more likely.
    Okay I think emet doesn’t try to protect ryne from the horror of sundering, yet I disagree thta he picked her solely to creep them out, as it’s literally just making an illusion of her copy.

    But anyway, idk what you guys even want. Nier collab is written by Ishikawa, the Word of God, basically. While it contains some pf emet’s perspective (which, yes, is bias), the rest are historical depiction that don’t contradict any info from shb. One other thing to remember, the souls are particularly important for the Ancients. Would it be far fetched to you to consider that when emet said the sundered are “malformed creatures”, it’s not only due to their physical appearance but also because of the souls?

    We have proof from anamnesis anyder that the sundered truly are smaller than the ancient btw
    (3)

  7. #7
    Player
    Iscah's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2017
    Posts
    14,308
    Character
    Aurelie Moonsong
    World
    Bismarck
    Main Class
    Red Mage Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Kozh View Post
    But anyway, idk what you guys even want. Nier collab is written by Ishikawa, the Word of God, basically. While it contains some pf emet’s perspective (which, yes, is bias), the rest are historical depiction that don’t contradict any info from shb. One other thing to remember, the souls are particularly important for the Ancients. Would it be far fetched to you to consider that when emet said the sundered are “malformed creatures”, it’s not only due to their physical appearance but also because of the souls?
    Perhaps you could phrase those ideas as a theory suggestion rather than an accusation? I don't think I've seen anyone in all this time propose that it might be to do with how Emet perceives the souls rather than the bodies of the sundered, and it actually seems quite plausible to help resolve the difference.

    As far as I've seen, discussions of the NieR story seem to revolve around "look, he really said they were really malformed creatures in this isolated story written by Ishikawa, even though the part of FFXIV also written by Ishikawa described it differently".

    It's Emet's word against Emet's, Ishikawa's word against Ishikawa's, in a part of the story that the game repeatedly shies away from examining in enough detail to verify which version is true.
    (7)

  8. #8
    Player
    Brinne's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2019
    Posts
    498
    Character
    Raelle Brinn
    World
    Ultros
    Main Class
    White Mage Lv 90
    Quote Originally Posted by Iscah View Post
    Ryne is not a child, she is described as a young woman – and Emet is trying to horrify them and convey the horror he felt. If he was trying to protect her poor childish sensibilities then surely he wouldn't have picked her to creep out with a duplicate?
    It's not really about sparing them - it's about him not making himself needlessly vulnerable by delving with extreme graphic detail into a horrifying, traumatic experience he had. Emet is demonstrably a very emotionally defensive sort at the same time he's trying to appeal to the Scions, which is what makes a lot of his behavior throughout Shadowbringers so interesting because of the resulting self-sabotage. But yeah, getting into debates over the precise nuances of Emet-Selch's characterization and his internal war with himself, as far as this context goes, is almost certainly a non-starter (I have been down this road before, lol!) It just comes down to "Do we take his direct POV as written in third-person or his dialogue simplifying things to an outside party as more reliable, if we're going with the 'he's unreliable' slant to justify dismissing one or the other'?" and how inherently silly it is to use a take by Emet-Selch to dismiss... a different take written around Emet-Selch.

    Either we accuse him of being inaccurate in one of those two passages or we accuse him of it in the other. All points considered, I think inaccuracy in the non-FFXIV story to be more likely.
    We know he's partially inaccurate in the Crystarium explanation. We know his demonstration never reflected the full scope of the physical reality of the Sundering as far back as 5.0 itself. People can take the interpretation they like, but I dunno, I'm more inclined to go with the one that hasn't already been demonstrated beyond doubt to be inaccurate, the one reflected in direct description and not second-hand dialogue, and the one written at least two years more recently to show events that, as of the writing of 5.0, the writers have fully admitted they didn't have the details or background fully planned out or in mind.

    Let me put it this way. An FFXIV fan decides to try out the Nier crossover because they heard, as advertised, it's about Emet-Selch and it's written by Ishikawa herself. When they read it, are they going to accept what it shows as perhaps an updated portrayal of the Sundering, or go into convolutions about how it doesn't precisely match up with a piece of exposition from 2+ years ago, so clearly this means that what Ishikawa has written is just Emet being nonsensical, and what a waste of time this all was, just shows more of Emet being overdramatic about what happened, etc, etc?

    Do you really think the latter take is what Ishikawa had in mind when she personally wrote this story after Endwalker?
    (9)
    Last edited by Brinne; 06-01-2023 at 03:10 AM.

  9. #9
    Player
    Ayche's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2021
    Posts
    328
    Character
    Aychelle Tripler
    World
    Raiden
    Main Class
    Paladin Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Cleretic View Post
    I dunno, I understood it well enough the moment I realized that meant the sahagin were probably the fragments/descendants of the guys who were Really Into Sharks.
    Quote Originally Posted by Lurina View Post
    I agree, but they said it, so we have no choice but to try and have it make sense. Or else we might wonder why we're on a forum devoted to obsessing over JRPG story minutia at all and have to question our life choices.
    I know this sounds really silly to say in the Lore forum, but sometimes less lore is better than more lore. Like in that QnA moment, you could had left it at "well sundered people started changing due to reduced aether" and that would had left enough mystery to it while also satisfying the question. The moment you gotta start thinking "Well uuuh, cat people, now cat people started appearing because uuuh there were ... a lot of ... mice..." you know you have gone too far. Miqote were not in FF14 because someone had something really profound to tell us that what if we were not evolved from apes, but cats instead...

    Sometimes things are aesthetic, but I think everyone already knew that.
    (8)

  10. #10
    Player
    tokinokanatae's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2019
    Posts
    194
    Character
    Amasar Ugund
    World
    Ultros
    Main Class
    Archer Lv 90
    Quote Originally Posted by Iscah View Post
    Either we accuse him of being inaccurate in one of those two passages or we accuse him of it in the other. All points considered, I think inaccuracy in the non-FFXIV story to be more likely.
    This is predicated on assuming you think both versions are incompatible, which is very strange to me, I must admit.

    Do you honestly picture the Sundering as Emet-Selch going about his day until, suddenly, lightning flashes and he is surrounded by coworkers exactly 1/14th the size they were prior, with no other differences? Come on, now.

    Your failure of imagination in regards to what 1/14th of a person's faculties would look like is your own problem. It's not a narrative inconsistency.
    (9)
    Last edited by tokinokanatae; 06-01-2023 at 03:29 AM.

Page 7 of 23 FirstFirst ... 5 6 7 8 9 17 ... LastLast