Page 4 of 23 FirstFirst ... 2 3 4 5 6 14 ... LastLast
Results 31 to 40 of 280

Hybrid View

  1. #1
    Player
    Brinne's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2019
    Posts
    498
    Character
    Raelle Brinn
    World
    Ultros
    Main Class
    White Mage Lv 90
    Quote Originally Posted by SannaR View Post
    What is an easier solution? Trying to squirrel away a small selection to try and fix the real problem in secret while ignoring a cycle of sacrific? Or to not allow said cycle to continue to perpetuate even if that means said new life is getting a crappy inheritance while still being able to aim to fix the real problem?
    I mean. I guess wholesale just killing everything would be an "easier solution" than trying to actually save lives, yeah...
    (7)

  2. #2
    Player
    SannaR's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2018
    Posts
    3,320
    Character
    Sanna Rosewood
    World
    Midgardsormr
    Main Class
    White Mage Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Brinne View Post
    I mean. I guess wholesale just killing everything would be an "easier solution" than trying to actually save lives, yeah...
    Isn't that sort of what happens with most great flood myths? God(s) feel man has committed too big of a sin and the world needs a reset. Or they have a fight and some feel the world needs a reset. I've never said the sundering is pretty. Heck I was hoping it was accidental. But I'm in the camp of those who accept it only on the basis of it had to happen due to the world the game takes place needing to exist and continue on. I like the unsundered world even if I might not like the conformity of it or at how blasé they about unmaking a creation in the same way we might be towards something we find just as mundane. I'd love to get a glimpse of a broader look at ancient life was outside of research facilities and the seat of government. I just accept that it probably won't happen and if it does it won't happen in the game.
    (7)

  3. #3
    Player
    Brinne's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2019
    Posts
    498
    Character
    Raelle Brinn
    World
    Ultros
    Main Class
    White Mage Lv 90
    This story is not presented as a myth, and Venat is not presented as a God. What happened is something we largely see play out in real-time before us with people we have tea with, help with mundane tasks, all while enjoying their charms and quirks and personality nuances. Much of the pathos of Venat's story is from meeting her as a person, and coming to understand that rather than a God, she was simply a single human person who made decisions on behalf of her vision of what humanity should be and her vision of the greater good for all of life and existence.

    The attempted re-painting of our encounters of the Ancients, and the actions they committed, both for good and ill, as 'simple myths' or 'ancient history' always feel weird to me, because this is a video game where there is no meaningful distinction between the NPCs we talk to and accept quests in the 'present' and the NPCs we talk to and accept quests from in the 'past' (which we can access simply by clicking the teleporation button.) Either way, in our immediate moment, we talk to them, get annoyed, laugh at them, engage with them equally as pretend-living people in front of us. Even beyond one of Shadowbringers's prime writing goals being stated explicitly as "humanizing the Ascians," Endwalker itself is as firm as it can be in the final word on the Ancients through things like the DoH quests, or G'raha's remark in Ultima Thule: they were simply people.

    "God" gets away with causing the great flood because he is a legitimate god, fundamentally inaccessible and incomprehensible. (And even then, opinions vary - I'm not religious myself, and the suggested nature of most 'gods' in theism is one factor as to why.) Venat is (and the rest of the Ancients, and the Ascians) explicitly a relatable human person, so suggesting we should downplay the decisions she, or the rest of them, made as relatable human people by acting otherwise is very strange and does the story a disservice in and of itself.

    If the argument is that "it had to happen because video game," sure, that's fine, but then I don't see much sense in actually meticulously parsing in-lore descriptions to try to figure out characters' actual reasoning and to contort things to try to make them reasonable from that position as well. Venat made a very weird, dissonant decision ultimately because Video Game and validating the player experience comes before all else, and the in-universe writing around it was kind of weird. It is what it is.
    (13)
    Last edited by Brinne; 05-30-2023 at 04:31 AM.

  4. #4
    Player
    Cleretic's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2021
    Location
    Solution Eight (it's not as good)
    Posts
    3,279
    Character
    Ein Dose
    World
    Mateus
    Main Class
    Alchemist Lv 100
    If it helps: Law in the SHin Megami Tensei games is essentially a Light-dominated scenario.

    ...wait, that doesn't help at all, there is very little chance that she knows enough about Shin Megami Tensei to get that.

    Okay, if you know Doctor Who: the Daleks would be Light-aligned.

    EDIT: In retrospect I think that might help even less
    (2)

  5. #5
    Player
    SannaR's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2018
    Posts
    3,320
    Character
    Sanna Rosewood
    World
    Midgardsormr
    Main Class
    White Mage Lv 100
    I also didn't mean for this to go in said direction. As until this entry was put into the game Zodiark from other entries according to some didn't feel as though he was shown in a good light. That and we also know that the devs when they change the phrasing of things it's supposed to serve a purpose. So the use of the new terms made me go why have they chosen to change it now to the ones they used. What is their aim with the use of said new terms and does anyone feel that it changes anything from how we have perceived them in the past. Obviously it's a no while at least to me aligning closer to the language that we got in ShB from Emet of how things happened and were treated as.
    (0)

  6. #6
    Player
    Denishia's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2019
    Location
    Gridania
    Posts
    475
    Character
    Denishia Squirrel
    World
    Brynhildr
    Main Class
    Fisher Lv 100
    Speaking of Codex Entries in general, we've completed our 'active' Scions entries with Thancred. Predictions on who's next aside from Zero? Lyse when she's allowed back into the main narrative or one of the other city state leaders?
    (0)

  7. #7
    Player
    Aneshda's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2019
    Posts
    580
    Character
    Deidrea Shadowbane
    World
    Twintania
    Main Class
    Pictomancer Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Denishia View Post
    Speaking of Codex Entries in general, we've completed our 'active' Scions entries with Thancred. Predictions on who's next aside from Zero? Lyse when she's allowed back into the main narrative or one of the other city state leaders?
    Emet Selch, Lahabrea, Athena, Erichthonios, Elidibus, Mitron, Loghrif, Nabriales, Igeyorhm, Zero, Minfilia, Moenbryda, Lamitt, Renda-Rae, Nyelbert, Varis, Nero, Gaius, Golbez, Rubicante
    (0)
    Someone call the Forum Police! Because I wrote passive aggressively that DT looks not good. Oh how right I was!

  8. #8
    Player
    Yuella's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2016
    Posts
    939
    Character
    Bulletproof Boyscout
    World
    Seraph
    Main Class
    Sage Lv 100
    Venat's is better because the ancients couldn't handle their sufferings because they're used to having perfect lives while the new life forms are not mortals and will learn how to deal with diseases and deaths and eventually learn how to find joy in sufferings, which is key to defeating Meteion. Also, the old lives were already dead and the new lives were still living. You do not sacrifice unwilling life forms who are still living to bring back dead people who willingly sacrificed themselves.
    (8)

  9. 05-30-2023 04:55 AM

  10. #10
    Player
    Teraq's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2016
    Location
    Amaurot
    Posts
    275
    Character
    Teraq Moks
    World
    Behemoth
    Main Class
    Ninja Lv 90
    Once again, this great community is grasping at straws to make the Convocation evil and Mommy good and right. OMG! The Convocation literally lined up every one in Amaurot and shot anyone who dissented! They made everyone goose-step right into the Zodiark furnace!!!

    Half sacrificed themselves; which means that the other half chose not to and that was fine.

    Quote Originally Posted by Lunaxia View Post
    So I threw Eric's lines from Pandaemonium into my favourite Japanese dictionary, as it's a modest step above Google Translate and I was curious. I'm not the guaranteed conveyor of nuance some of you are searching for, but for those also interested:

    In English, he says "I must defy the directive (of the Convocation.)"

    In Japanese, it's "(十四人委員会)の方針に従わない." 方針 is defined as a "course, line or policy", while 従う (which Eric uses in the negative) means generally "to obey" or "to follow", seemingly both in the loose and absolute sense of the word. xの方針に従う typically translates in most instances as "abide by, follow or comply with x's policy."

    So on reflection, I actually think SE's original translation is quite accurate here, given that "directive" to my mind has a similar nuance of "instruction" or "direction" the original Japanese possesses, and makes more sense given the context than alternative translations. My own interpretation of the matter is, being the approximation of our government, they put out an official guideline on how they planned to deal with the Final Days that they expected the citizens would naturally comply with as a matter of course, given the general view of the Ancients was that they lived to better their star; I don't think the Convocation would even have thought to give direct orders, as it was beyond the bounds of consideration that they wouldn't, if that makes sense?

    Japanese has other words for more concrete forms of command (the word I see most often used in that context is 命令, which means "order"), so while this is merely my take on it, I do believe that's more what they were trying to suggest with that wording. Anyone with more insight is free to correct me, of course.
    Thank you for your sanity. FR says "Hence, I do not intend to follow the directives of the Convocation", and I do believe it's been shown time and again that FR as a localisation is much closer to an actual translation of the original Japanese than whatever the English team is doing.
    (As an aside, FR Lahabrea also does not call his future self a "hypocrite" or say anything about "surface level" or whatever. He merely says it was foolish to use the Heart of Sabik because he inadvertently helped along Athena's plans.)

    Nothing to me points at a harsh command or obligation. Of course they actually needed to power Zodiark, and from what we see of Amaurot there was pretty much nothing left by then but humans themselves. The situation was desperate. And still it seemed to boil down to a choice people were free to make.

    By the way, portraying Emet-Selch, the Angel of Truth, as an unreliable narrator while the opposing side, Venat, has been known to keep vital secrets and lie for twelve thousand years straight, is high grade copium. Emet-Selch, as an actual sitting member of the Convocation at the time, would have been privy to everything entailing their conduct. Venat did not. But still: if you're going to dismiss Emet as an unreliable narrator because of underlying motivations, then you should extend the same courtesy to Venat the duplicitous.

    God. This community and its shameless Ancient hate. No wonder Endwalker was liked.

    Quote Originally Posted by Lunaxia View Post
    It's a little funny to me that the aim of this thread, even if meant with all the good faith in the world, was effectively to call attention to how the Convocation might have conceivably ordered the Ancients to kill themselves, before proceeding to subtly highlight in contrast the morality of Venat's actions by pointing out how she wanted to preserve new life of potential importance...
    of course lmao
    (6)
    Last edited by Teraq; 05-30-2023 at 07:32 AM.

Page 4 of 23 FirstFirst ... 2 3 4 5 6 14 ... LastLast