


The only time WHM and AST is somewhat similar is in early levels tho..
AST starts to gain much of its identity after the lvl 60 mark.
I used to be WHM main, but once i learned AST..
I discarded WHM and never looked back lol
Last edited by Zeastria; 02-23-2024 at 07:44 AM.
☆SCH/AST/DNC/VPR/SMN☆
Same here I started whm at first too(picked up the game on its stormblood release)I still want stormblood ast honestly and I was more of a noct lover than dirunal. I love shield healing over hot healing xD, but yes overall never wanted to touch whm again. Hence am sage main because it gives a slight feel of old noct ast, (rather instant shields even if weaker) than having to sit and plan/pre cast shields. Old cards too was just much much better and fun sigh.




^because of the skills you listed only malefic and combust you are regularly going to actually press, going by combined similarity of the entire toolkit is next to pointless, it’s only the similarity of the bread and butter kits (which is why SGE feels different enough from SCH to not cause a riot even though SGE is just a less clunky clone of SCH)
When you pull them back to their bread and butter kits
1) AST- CU, CO, ES
2) WHM- lilys
They really don’t heal in a very similar way already




As an aside, what do SCH mains think about making Demi-Seraph summoning works like its PvP iteration?
Basically: a ground targeted marker to summon the seraph at, and she’ll stay there until timer runs out. No moving allowed. Eos/Carb can stay active. You will of course lose the blue colored Whispering Dawn & Illumination. Consolation remains as it is. Other fae skill will still originate from your Fae/Carb.
"Outside obvious jokes/sarcasm, I aim to convey my words to the future readers who may come across mine posts. Can I change -your- mind, somehow? Potentially... but that's not why I'm writing. You and I have wrote our piece(s). We don't necessarily need to change each other's mind. But we can change other's."




I don’t oppose that change but I just don’t really think it’s needed, consolation has a 30 yalm radius so positioning seraph is completely unnecessary, you can basically skip the middle man of ground placement by just making eos cast consolation, if not like you are struggling to find positions to make eos do something considering she only has 6 skills totalAs an aside, what do SCH mains think about making Demi-Seraph summoning works like its PvP iteration?
Basically: a ground targeted marker to summon the seraph at, and she’ll stay there until timer runs out. No moving allowed. Eos/Carb can stay active. You will of course lose the blue colored Whispering Dawn & Illumination. Consolation remains as it is. Other fae skill will still originate from your Fae/Carb.



I'm not opposed to it, but it wouldn't fix the main issue with Seraph. I've played matches where the excog effect hits too late and people die, that delay as she spawns in to heal is still there, she also will still ghost if you use the follow-up button near the end of her timer.As an aside, what do SCH mains think about making Demi-Seraph summoning works like its PvP iteration?
Basically: a ground targeted marker to summon the seraph at, and she’ll stay there until timer runs out. No moving allowed. Eos/Carb can stay active. You will of course lose the blue colored Whispering Dawn & Illumination. Consolation remains as it is. Other fae skill will still originate from your Fae/Carb.
I guess it's a good thing that she doesn't spawn from the fairy itself? That would solve some ghosting. But I think planning around not needing Dissipation/Fey Blessing when you use Seraph is more engaging.
I would rather just demote Seraph to glamour state and just have Rouse to power up my Carbuncle's healing.As an aside, what do SCH mains think about making Demi-Seraph summoning works like its PvP iteration?
Basically: a ground targeted marker to summon the seraph at, and she’ll stay there until timer runs out. No moving allowed. Eos/Carb can stay active. You will of course lose the blue colored Whispering Dawn & Illumination. Consolation remains as it is. Other fae skill will still originate from your Fae/Carb.
Thinking about a healer mechanic were you have an oGCD damage attack that can be used frequently (20-40 recast time), and when used it allows either your standard single target or AOE heal spell to be cast instantly. And if you do choose to use your now instant heal GCD, it will reduce the cooldown of the attack that procced it.




That much concern, I don't disagree. I'm mainly trying to think up ways to keep the Demi-Seraph while also reducing the disasterrific delay they introduce because IMHO it's super unlikely SE would remove the entire summon and replace it with Rouse despite its better functions. To their eyes, it's like "omg we lost some pretty big 'ultimate' summon!!".
It would be nice if she would finish whatever her last command is even after the timer's up before leaving the battlefield.
Last edited by Rein_eon_Osborne; 02-23-2024 at 04:23 PM.
"Outside obvious jokes/sarcasm, I aim to convey my words to the future readers who may come across mine posts. Can I change -your- mind, somehow? Potentially... but that's not why I'm writing. You and I have wrote our piece(s). We don't necessarily need to change each other's mind. But we can change other's."



I honestly think they could fix it (and SMN) by introducing a new ability that aspects your summon, doesn't have to remove them from the field, just a twinkle and they change to the other model. Like 'Aspect: Eos', 'Aspect: Selene', 'Aspect: Seraph', then you just give SCH 2 stacks of Rouse and give SMN Enkindle, Rouse will make the fairy do their signature thing, maybe Eos (Fey Blessing), Selene (some new shield ability) and Seraph (Consolation).That much concern, I don't disagree. I'm mainly trying to think up ways to keep the Demi-Seraph while also reducing the disasterrific delay they introduce because IMHO it's super unlikely SE would remove the entire summon and replace it with Rouse despite its better functions. To their eyes, it's like "omg we lost some pretty big 'ultimate' summon!!".
Then they can do the same thing for SMN with 'Aspect: Ruby', 'Aspect: Topaz' and 'Aspect: Emerald', the Carbuncle just changes colours and you can Enkindle it for Ifrit's, Titan's and Garuda's ultimates.
|
|
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
|
|
Cookie Policy
This website uses cookies. If you do not wish us to set cookies on your device, please do not use the website. Please read the Square Enix cookies policy for more information. Your use of the website is also subject to the terms in the Square Enix website terms of use and privacy policy and by using the website you are accepting those terms. The Square Enix terms of use, privacy policy and cookies policy can also be found through links at the bottom of the page.


Reply With Quote



