Items that can only be used once should be Greed-only after usage

[nothbr]

You know, things that can be sold (either to an NPC or the Marketboard) but can only be actually used once, like Minions, Triple Triad Cards, Orchestrion Rolls and such.

When you get those in dungeon/raid chests and you have already used them, they should become Greed-only, in order for you to still be able to get and sell them if you want, but without harming those who don't have the item yet. The preference is their, and if everyone has it or don't want it at all, feel free to greed and get it and sell.

Of course, it opens the possibility to a practice of "I'm never gonna use this item in order to always Need and sell", but I believe the amount of people doing this would be pretty low, enough to not make this a problem.

[Selsix]

I see your point and agree with your sentiment but I don't think this would fix the problem. People who want to sell the item will just refrain from using it themselves at all or at least until the content becomes irrelevant or the item becomes worthless. I know you addressed this, but I disagree with you that the number of people doing this would be minimal.

[R041]

I straight up don't think they should be sellable at all. Takes away from the actual engaging part of playing the game's content.

[Bacent]

I've made a thread or two about this before and had people saying 'why does your collection matter more than me getting MGP

I just wish they were back to the 'drops in inventory' like they used to be

[Ascended_Demon]

I've made a thread or two about this before and had people saying 'why does your collection matter more than me getting MGP

I just wish they were back to the 'drops in inventory' like they used to be

Aren't TT cards only subject to loot rules in alliance raids? How do people say that and not notice?

[AshtonCrowe]

You know, things that can be sold (either to an NPC or the Marketboard) but can only be actually used once, like Minions, Triple Triad Cards, Orchestrion Rolls and such.

When you get those in dungeon/raid chests and you have already used them, they should become Greed-only, in order for you to still be able to get and sell them if you want, but without harming those who don't have the item yet. The preference is their, and if everyone has it or don't want it at all, feel free to greed and get it and sell.

Of course, it opens the possibility to a practice of "I'm never gonna use this item in order to always Need and sell", but I believe the amount of people doing this would be pretty low, enough to not make this a problem.

They should be tracking that properly yes, NEED means you need it in your collection / do not have it. If person has already obtained it they're 100% gunna sell it. It's why i solo content and when i don't i have loot master on.

[CaptainLagbeard]

I wonder if the Spaghetti code would allow the item to be used instantly upon acquiring it if you Need roll for something.

[Iscah]

Very few people are going to deliberately not use a thing so they can sell it for a pittance.

Also, Triple Triad cards from alliance raids should be marked unique so one person can't win multiple in one shot.

[Vahlnir]

TT cards? I can agree with that approach. Not so much about everything else. I say this as someone who loses everything 90% of the time.

[RitsukoSonoda]

IMO the thing they should have done all the way back in 1.0 is have the game remember what duty drops you've obtained and make it so you can only roll need on something if you never obtained it before.